Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1919

Hunt v. Guerin

Hunt v. Guerin
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided July 14, 1919 · No. 10234 · Gage
99 S.E. 809; 112 S.C. 305; 1919 S.C. LEXIS 119 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Mr. Francis F. Carroll , for appellant, submits: That A. Morton Hunt died a resident of Dorchester county: 107 S.C. 209 ; 17 S.C. Eq., p. 1. Messrs. Miller, Huger, Wilbur Miller , for respondent, submit: This being a matter relating to the probate of a will, it is exclusively a law matter triable on the law side of the Court, and the issue made on the question of jurisdiction being solely a question of fact, the concurrent findings of the probate Judge and the Circuit Judge are conclusive and not reviewable in this Court: Vol. I, Code of 1912, secs. 34, 77; 74 S.C. 189 ; 3 S.C. 531 ; 73 S.C. 79 ; 15 S.C. 80 ; 19 S.C. 604 ; 43 S.C. 338 ; 21 S.C. 338 ; 21 S.C. 272 ; 25 S.C. 381 ; 26 S.C. 298 ; 2 S.C. 24 ; 40 S.C. 276 ; 18 S.E. 794 ; 13 S.C. 37 ; 18 S.C. 198 ; 20 S.C. 471 ; 80 Rich. 90; 35 S.C. 417 ; 14 S.E. 931 ; 82 S.C. 42 ; 12 Rich. Eq. 196; 74 S.C. 189 ; 53 S.E. 170 ; 104 S.C. 339 . Even if reviewable, the decision of the Circuit Judge is certainly not "opposed to the clear weight of the testimony," and even in equity cases the findings of fact of the probate Court will not be interfered with unless they appear to be (in the language of Mr. Justice Woods in the case of In re Solomon's Estate, supra), "opposed to the clear weight of the testimony." 13 S.C. 87 ; 18 S.C. 193 .

Hunt v. Guerin

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Justice Gage.

The issue tried is the legal residence of one A. Morton Hunt, lately dead, testate, at Charleston. The will was offered for probate, at Charleston, but issue was made that *307 the adjoining county of Dorchester was the residence of the testator, and that the will ought, therefore, to be proved in that county.

The probate Court of Charleston sustained its jurisdiction, and the Circuit Court on appeal affirmed that judgment. And that is the sole issue here.

The testimony warrants a conclusion either way, and in such circumstances the judgment must be affirmed; ahd it is so ordered. Solomon’s case, 74 S. C. 189, 54 S. E. 207.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.