Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1923

People's Bank of Rock Hill v. People's Bank of Anderson

People's Bank of Rock Hill v. People's Bank of Anderson
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided January 18, 1923 · No. 11107 · Gary, Fraser, Watts, Marion, Cothran
115 S.E. 736; 122 S.C. 476; 1923 S.C. LEXIS 24 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Messrs. Bonham Allen and J. Harry Foster , for appellant, cite: Recordation under unconstitutional act no notice: Const., 1895, Art. 3, Sec. 34, Subd. 9; 60 S.C. 501 ; 59 S.C. 110 ; 56 S.C. 516 ; 51 S.C. 54 ; 85 D.C., 186; Sec. 1356, I Civ. Code 1912, is null and void: Past indebtedness not sufficient consideration to constitute relation of purchaser for valuable consideration without notice: 106 S.C. 430 ; 49 S.C. 469 . Messrs. Spencer White , for respondent, cite: Sec. 1356 is constitutional: 61 S.C. 205 ; 73 S.C. 194 ; 100 S.C. 479 . Where part only of act is unconstitutional, balance will stand: 109 S.C. 1 ; 76 S.C. 34 ; 30 S.C. 360 . Special provisions permissible in general law: 109 S.C. 1 ; 76 S.C. 194 . Past indebtedness not sufficient consideration to make party a purchaser for value without notice: 106 S.C. 425 ; 49 S.C. 469 ; 43 S.C. 28 ; 45 S.C. 83 . Warehouse receipt not negotiable: 101 S.C. 381 .

People's Bank of Rock Hill v. People's Bank of Anderson

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. ChiEE .Justice Gary.

*484For the reasons therein stated the decree of his Honor, the Circuit Judge, is affirmed.

Mr. Justice Watts concurs. Mr. Justice Marion concurs in result.

Opinion of the Court

January 18, 1923. The opinion of the Court was delivered by For the reasons therein stated the decree of his Honor, the Circuit Judge, is affirmed.

MR. JUSTICE WATTS concurs.

MR. JUSTICE MARION concurs in result.

MR. JUSTICE FRASER: I dissent.

I cannot see how this act can be constitutional. Eight counties are exempt from its operation. "Provided that this act shall not apply to the counties of Sumter," etc. The named counties are entirely exempt from its operation. It cannot be successfully held that we may strike out the unconstitutional proviso and leave the act there, so that the act applies to the whole state. It cannot operate in Abbeville County, because the statute specifically says it shall not. No reason has been suggested for a difference in the recording laws.

It seems to me that, as to the $520.34, the appellant should be protected.

MR. JUSTICE COTHRAN concurs.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.