Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1927

Drafts v. State Highway Department

Drafts v. State Highway Department
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided October 31, 1927 · No. 12303 · Chiee, Watts, Messrs, Cothran, Brease, Stabrer, Carter
140 S.E. 468; 142 S.C. 202; 1927 S.C. LEXIS 190 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Messrs. Martin Sturkie , and E.L. Asbill , for appellants, cite: Act No. 189 of General Assembly, 1925, to amend Sec. 2948 Code is constitutional: 139 S.C. 321 . This action survives: 101 S.C. 48 ; Sec. 375, Code Proc.; 59 S.C. 577 ; Sec. 2950, Code. Contra holding in 29 S.C. 161 , overruled: 101 S.C. 48 . Messrs. John M. Daniel, Cordie Page and Timmerman Graham , for respondent, cite: Cases distinguished: 135 S.E., 62. Act No. 189, General Assembly, 1925, does not state the general subject of legislation sought to be accomplished by the body of the Act: 116 S.C. 196 . Court cannot restate the language of an Act to make it agree to some possible conclusion as to its intention; bound by language used: 113 S.C. 101 ; 103 S.C. 23 ; 99 S.C. 220 ; 62 S.C. 57 ; 13 S.C. 46 ; 111 S.C. 18 . Controlling in case at bar: 29 S.C. 166 ; 40 S.C. 344 . Cases distinguished: 101 S.C. 55 .

Drafts v. State Highway Department

Addendum

On Petition for Rehearing

Per curiam.

Rehearing denied. Petition dismissed.

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. ChiEE Justice Watts.

*206 This is an action by Douvinia Drafts, as administratrix of the estate of Thomas I. Drafts, deceased, against the State Highway Department of South Carolina. The defendant interposed a demurrer which was sustained by his Honor S. W. G. Shipp at the March term of Court, 1926, at Lexington, S. C. Notice of appeal was duly and timely served.

There are eight exceptions, and the judgment must be reversed under the recent case of Scott v. Town of Brook-land and State Highway Department of South Carolina, 139 S. C., 321; 138 S. E., 32. The action survives under Code of Laws and McLendon v. City of Columbia, 101 S. C., 48; 85 S. E., 234; 5 A. L. R., 990.

Judgment reversed.

Messrs. Justices. Cothran, Brease, Stabrer, and Carter concur.

Concurring Opinion

Mr. Justice Cothran

(concurring in dismissal of petition) : In his order sustaining the demurrer to the complaint, his Honor, Judge Shipp, passed upon only one point: That the Act of 1925 (34 Stat. 287), was unconstitutional as violative of Const. Art. 3, §17, which provides:

“Every act or resolution having the force of law shall relate to but one subject, and that shall be expressed in the title.”

His ruling was the same in the case at bar as in the case of Scott v. Brookland, 139 S. C., 321; 138 S. E., 32, which was overruled by this Court.

The other questions raised in the petition for a rehearing were not passed upon by Judge Shipp and were not properly before this Court upon the appeal; they are still open if the defendant should hereafter wish to have them presented.

Messrs. Justices Brease and Carter concur.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.