Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1927

Watson v. Charleston Stevedoring Co.

Watson v. Charleston Stevedoring Co.
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided October 13, 1927 · No. 12285 · Cothran, Ci-Iiee, Watts, Messrs, Beease, Stabler, Carter
139 S.E. 778; 141 S.C. 355; 1927 S.C. LEXIS 81 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Messrs. H.L. Erckmann and B.H. Mathews , for appellant, cite: Evidence of negligence: 123 S.C. 205; 69 S.C. 530. Same, prima facie: 93 S.C. 396; 91 S.C. 128; 126 S.C. 326; 35 S.C. 407 ; 101 S.C. 83; 133 S.E., 551; 18 S.C. 279 ; 81 S.C. 203 ; 206 Fed., 415; 109 Fed., 665; 29 Cyc., 595; 86 S.C. 137 ; 158 Fed., 54. Cases distinguished: 72 S.C. 402; 126 S.C. 231 ; 128 S.C. 390 ; 122 S.C. 359 ; 97 S.C. 112 . Messrs. Mitchell Horlbeck , for respondent, cite: Law as to "Res Ipsa Loquitur": 122 S.C. 359 ; 126 S.C. 231 ; 128 S.C. 390 ; 97 S.C. 112 ; 69 S.C. 529 . Bare proof of the machinery or appliance breaking or failing to function is of itself not enough to warrant sending case to jury: 128 S.C. 390 , 392 ; 72 S.C. 402; 122 S.C. 359 ; 97 S.C. 112 ; 48 S.E., 538 . Cases distinguished: 126 S.C. 326; 35 S.C. 407 ; 93 S.C. 395 ; 101 S.C. 83; 135 S.C. 167; 18 S.C. 279 ; 81 S.C. 203 ; 123 S.C. 199 ; 91 S.C. 127 . Master charged with exercising reasonable care in furnishing safe place in which to work; not a guarantor of such safety: 134 S.C. 31 .

Watson v. Charleston Stevedoring Co.

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Justice Cothran.

The order of his Honor, Judge Bonham, granting a non-suit in this case, is entirely satisfactory, and for the reasons stated by him is affirmed.

Mr. Ci-iiee Justice Watts and Messrs. Justices BeeasE, Stabler and Carter concur.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.