Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1931

Sartor v. Fidelity & Deposit Co.

Sartor v. Fidelity & Deposit Co.
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided May 26, 1931 · Cothran, Chiee, Brease, Carter, Cos-Grove, Stabler
158 S.E. 819; 160 S.C. 390; 1931 S.C. LEXIS 88 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Mr. John K. Hamblin , for appellants, cites: Guardian should not spend in excess of annual income of ward's estate: 3 Strob. Eq., 31. If he does he should be required to make a showing sufficient to have warranted the expenditure in advance: 113 S.C. 223 ; 82 S.C. 109 ; 63 S.E., 128 . Account must be stated on annual basis: 72 S.E., 732. Continuing default: 18 S.C. 366 . Parent as guardian entitled to claim credit for benefits of infants: 21 S.C. 590 , 111 Pac., 884; 24 N.E., 565; 85 N.W., 689; 159 Pac., 317 ; 43 A.L.R., 595; 28 C.J., 1118, 1119. In absence of intention by guardian to charge estate of ward for support, etc., surety will not be permitted to prove such amounts as set-off: 36 L.R.A. (N.S.), 252, 89 A.S.R., 297; 60 S.E., 85. Court cannot authorize guardian to borrow funds of ward: 212 Pac., 103; 30 A.L.R., 45; 1 S.C. 209 ; 28 C.J., 1298. Subrogation: 118 S.C. 239 ; 99 S.C. 352 ; 109 S.C. 196 . Guardian liable for improper loan: 93 S.C. 300 ; 15 A. E. Enc. of Law, 2nd Ed., 107; 109 S.C. 197 . Messrs. Hughes Russell , for respondent Surety, cite: Surety may file an accounting for a truant principal: 113 S.C. 222 ; 102 S.E., 20 . Father under legal duty to support children: Bailey Eq., 279; 40 S.E., 611; 57 L.R.A., 738; 93 A.S.R., 933. Situation different with mother where father is dead: 34 S.C. 496 ; 13 S.E., 676 . Courts will allow father for future maintenance out of ward's estate: 2 Strob. Eq., 1. And to mothers: 3 DeS., 256; 4 DeS., 445. Where father as guardian seeks allowance for past maintenance showing must be different: 2 DeS., 94; 2 McCord's Eq., 214; 214 Bailey's Eq., 279; 2 McCord's Eq., 43; 5 Rich. Eq., 31; 1 S.C. 337 ;.

Sartor v. Fidelity & Deposit Co.

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Justice Cothran.

This Court is entirely satisfied with the decree of his Honor Judge Sease affirming the report of the Probate Judge, and the same is accordingly affirmed.

Mr. Chiee Justice Brease, Mr. Acting Justice Carter, and Mr. Acting Associate Justice John I. Cos-grove concur. Mr. Justice Stabler concurs in result.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.