Supreme Court of South Carolina, 1936

Farley v. American Surety Co. of New York

Farley v. American Surety Co. of New York
Supreme Court of South Carolina · Decided December 1, 1936 · No. 14389 · Stabler, Messrs, Bonham, Baker, Fisi-Iburne, Gaston
188 S.E. 776; 182 S.C. 187; 1936 S.C. LEXIS 20 (South Eastern Reporter)

Counsel

Messrs. Grier, Park, McDonald Todd , for appellant, cite: Notice of loss: 21 R.C.L., 1073; 80 S.C. 151 ; 177 S.C. 363 ; 37 F.2d 550 ; 171 S.C. 1 ; 171 S.C. 123 ; 158 S.C. 394 ; 75 F.2d 23 ; 4 F.2d 203 ; 125 F., 887; 24 N.W., 451; 183 U.S. 402 ; 197 Mass. 101 ; 125 A.S.R., 332; 69 F.2d 147 ; 58 F.2d 7 ; 52 F.2d 709 . Where failure to give notice excused: 37 S.C. 69 ; 15 S.E., 344 ; 60 A., 1009 ; 58 A., 1057; 46 S.E., 678; 89 Am. Rep., 777; 78 S.C. 73 ; 75 A.L.R., 1503. Receiver takes assets as trustee: 3 R.C.L., 679; 125 S.C. 332 ; 136 S.C. 111 ; L.R.A., 1916-F., 709; 42 F.2d 953 ; 56 A.L.R., 1247; 64 F.2d 413 ; 146 U.S. 499 ; 208 U.S. 541 . Notice to agent is notice to principal if agent acting for principal: 50 S.C. 259 ; 39 S.C. 294 ; 145 S.C. 91 ; 48 A.L.R., 459; 21 R.C.L., 838; 2 L.R.A. (N.S.), 994; 110 U.S. 7 ; 37 F.2d 452 ; 165 F., 602. Messrs. Mays Featherstone, B.W. Crouch, Jeff D. Griffith and M.J. Yarbrough , for respondent, cite: Surety is an insurer and contract to be construed most favorably to party protected thereby: 163 F., 690; 13 F.2d 758 : 20 F.2d 514 ; 21 F.2d 744 ; 28 F.2d 698 ; 30 F.2d 56 ; 191 U.S. 416 ; 24 S.Ct., 142 ; 48 L.Ed., 242 ; 200 U.S. 197 ; 26 S.Ct., 168 ; 50 L.Ed., 437 ; 244 U.S. 376 ; 37 S.Ct., 614 ; 61 L.Ed., 1206 . Failure to give notice of loss: 8 F.2d 678 ; 137 Iowa, 490 ; 115 N.W., 24 ; 126 A.S.R., 290; 133 P., 782; Ann. Cas., 1915-B., 1272; 142 P., 1077; Ann. Ca., 1916-B., 238; 122 A., 484 ; 33 A.L.R., 489; 16 F.2d 847 . Notice to agent: 156 S.C. 480 ; 153 S.E., 462 ; 129 S.C. 531 ; 24 L.Ed., 779 ; 7 R. C.L., 657; 2 C.J., 868; 74 S.C. 368 ; 54 S.E., 658 ; 114 A.S.R., 1004; 50 S.C. 259 ; 27 S.E., 962 ; 170 U.S. 156 ; 42 L.Ed., 986 ; 11 Wall, 356; 20 L.Ed., 167 .

Farley v. American Surety Co. of New York

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Mr. Chief Justice Stabler.

This appeal is from an order overruling a demurrer to the complaint. The action was commenced in June, 1933. In so far as the appellant, American Surety Company of New York, is concerned, the suit is upon a fiduciary bond issued by it in November, 1912,- and in which Milledge T. Pitts, formerly president of Planters National Bank of Saluda, and who died in December, 1930, was the principal. The bond, which is set out as an exhibit to the complaint, contained the usual coverage found in bonds of this kind, and was continuous in its operation, being renewed, from year to year merely by the payment of yearly premiums.

*206 We have given careful consideration to the questions-raised by the exceptions; and, while we are not in agreement with all that is said in the Circuit Order, we think, under the facts alleged in the complaint and admitted by the demurrer to be true, Judge Sease reached the correct conclusion. We therefore approve the result of his decree. See Peurifoy, Receiver, v. Loyal et al., 154 S. C., 267, 151 S. E., 579; Garner v. Volunteer State Life Insurance Company, 171 S. C., 1, 171 S. E., 370; Lee v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, 180 S. C., 475, 186 S. E., 376.

The judgment of the Circuit Court is affirmed.

Messrs. Justices Bonham, Baker and Fisi-iburne and Mr. Acting Associate Justice A. E. Gaston concur.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.