Town of Wayne v. Caldwell
Town of Wayne v. Caldwell
Opinion of the Court
This is an appeal from an order of the circuit court setting aside a verdict, and vacating a judgment rendered -in a matter of damages arising by reason of the board of supervisors of the town of Wayne laying out and establishing a
The case at bar was brought to the circuit court by an appeal from the action of the board of supervisors of Wayne township in assessing damages in laying out a road across the the land of appellant. The action of the board of supervisors was based upon Sections 1296-1305, Comp. Laws, inclusive, relating to altering, discontinuing, and laying out roads. The altering and laying out of roads for the use of the public is taking private property for public use, and every substantial requirement of the statute must be complied with by the supervisors of a town; otherwise their proceedings will be void.
The sections above enumerated provide, with great particularity, the mode and manner of procedure. Some of the requirements pertain to private individuals alone, and, as to them, the manner of procedure may be waived by the parties interested, but that portion of the statute in which the public have a general interest must be strictly followed in order to be valid. The face of the proceedings had before the board of supervisors, as disclosed by the affidavits of one of the town supervisors and the town clerk, shows clearly that the supervisors failed to proceed in the manner prescribed by the statute. It is not necessary to examine or point out more than one of these irregularities and ommissions to comply with the statute upon the part of the town supervisors, as that is fatal to this appeal.
This being the case, there was nothing for the appellant to appeal from to the circuit court. The action of the board in relation to assessing damages to the appellant, was of no force or effect. A highway is not legally fid out unless the board of
The making and filing this order is the final culmination of the proceedings. Without the order, no conclusion has been arrived at by the board, and, without the record of it, no publication to the public has been made that a 'road has been established, as called for by the petition. If no road has been laid out, or land taken belonging to appellant, for public use, she has no claim for damages, and there is nothing from which she could appeal. It is the notice of appeal that gives the appellate court jurisdiction, and from .this it appears that there has never been any filing of the order laying out said road. in the office of the town clerk. This failure leaves the parties in the same condition they were in before any proceedings were had in relation to laying out the road in question. There being nothing to appeal from, the circuit court took jurisdiction of nothing, and could determine nothing. Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Cited By
- 16 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. When judicial tribunals have no jurisdiction of the subject matter on which they assume to act, their proceedings are absolutely void; but, when they have jurisdiction of the subject matter, irregularities or illegality in their proceedings does not render them absolutely void, though they may be avoided by timely and proper objection. 2. A court which is competent by its constitution to decide on its jurisdiction in a given case can determine that question at any time in the proceedings of the cause, whenever that fact is made to appear to its satisiaction, either before or after judgment. 3. The altering and laying out of roads for the use of the public is taking private property for pubic use, and every substantial requirement of the statute must be complied with by the supervisors of the town; otherwise their proceedings will be void. 4. The statutory requirements which pertain to private individuals alone, as to the manner of procedure, may be waived by the parties interested, but that portion of the statute in which the public have a general interest must be strictly followed in order to make the proceeding valid. 5. The survey, and an accurate description of the highway laid out, must be incorporated into an order, and sig'ned by the board, and such order, together with the petition, service of notice and award of damages, must be filed in the office of the town clerk, within five days after its date, and,' if not filed within twenty days, they shall be deemed to have decided ag’ainst such application by operation of law. 6. The making and filing of this order is the final culmination of the whole proceeding. Without the order, no conclusion has been arrived at by the board, and the parties are left in the same condition they were in before any proceedings were had in relation to laying out the road in question. (Syllabus by the Court.