Western Twine Co. v. Scott
Western Twine Co. v. Scott
Opinion of the Court
This is an action on promissory notes not due when it was commenced. The only allegations in the complaint intended to avoid the effect of bringing suit before maturity of the claims sued upon are as follows: 1 ‘That at the time of the commencement of this action the clerk of this court, upon an affidavit stating that the debt herein was incurred for property obtained under false pretenses, issued a writ of attachment directed to the sheriff of Minnehaha county, requiring him to attach and safely keep all the property of the defendants within said county; that under and by virtue of said writ of attachment the said sheriff has levied upon and now holds, the property of these defendants.” After answering, the defendants moved the court upon traverse affidavits to discharge the attachment, which motion was denied. Upon the trial, after introducing its notes, plaintiff offered the affidavit, undertaking and 'warrant of attachment, and order sustaining the same, which were excluded by the court, and defendants moved for a dismissal of the action upon the ground, among others, that ‘ ‘there is no allegation in the complaint sufficient to support the action before the claim is due.” This motion was sustained, and
A creditor may bring an action on a claim before it is due when the debt was incurred for property obtained under false pretenses (Comp. Laws, § 5014; Finch v. Armstrong [9 S. D. 255] N. W. 740); but the fact that the debt was so incurred must be alleged in the complaint. It is the existence of this fact which authorizes suit prior to the maturity of the claim. The attach
Reference
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. In an action under Comp. Laws, § 5014, on a debt not due, incurred for property obtained under false pretenses, the complaint must allege that the debt was so incurred, it not being sufficient that such allegation is contained merely in an affidavit in attachment filed in the same suit, and referred to in the complaint. 2. Attachment proceedings, showing that a debt was incurred for property obtained under false pretenses, are not admissible as evidence under a complaint on an unmatured debt, brought under Comp. Laws, l 5014, where the complaint fails to allege such fact.