Randall v. Burk Twp.
Randall v. Burk Twp.
Opinion of the Court
Upon the trial of this action the defendants objected to the introduction of any evidence, for the reason that the complaint does not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action; pointing out specifically the respects wherein the complaint is defective. Thereupon plaintiffs offered in evidence the following stipulation made in open court upon a preceding trial of the same cause: “It is stipulated and agreed in open court by and between the parties to this action that the only issue to be tried and1 determined by the court is whether the survey made by E. H. Van Antwerp, deputy county surveyor of Minnehaha county, óf the lines in Burk township, in the year 1887, is in accordance with the government survey thereof, and that no objection will be made to the sufficiency of the complaint for said purpose, or to the jurisdiction of the court. It is further stipulated and agreed that, if the court finds said survey by E. H. Van Antwerp to be in accordance with the government survey, he shall render judgment for the defendants; and, if he finds that it is not in accordance with the government survey, he shall render judgment for the plaintiffs.” Defendants objected to the stipulation, and asked leave to show why they should be relieved therefrom. Such leave was granted, and they showed by an uncontradicted affidavit: That “at the time the stipulation was made, many of the land-owners in said township had not accepted the lines as
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Randall v. Burk Twp. of Minnehaha County
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- In an action to enjoin the opening of roads and the assessment of real estate according to section lines, where a defendant township entered into a stipulation limiting the issues to the question whether a survey locating such lines conformed to government lines, and waiving objections to the pleadings, it was not an abuse of discretion for the court, on a second trial, to permit it to show that, since becoming a party to the stipulation, nearly all the property owners within it had recognized such survey as correct, and that the highways and property rights of persons not parties to the suit had been adjusted on the basis thereof, and for such reasons to release it from the stipulation; at the same time permitting plaintiff to amend without terms.