Congdon & Henry Hardware Co. v. Grand Island & W. C. R.
Congdon & Henry Hardware Co. v. Grand Island & W. C. R.
Opinion of the Court
This is an action to foreclose a mechanic’s lien f j • certain supplies furnished to the subcontractors Carroll & Donoghut,
The roadbed of the railroad was constructed by Fitzgerald & Bro. under a contract with the company for the construction of its line of road from the Cheyenne river, through the counties of Fall River, Custer,'and Pennington to the station of Kirk, in Dawrence county, 106 miles. Certain sections of this line were let by Fitzgerald & Bro. to Carroll & Donoghue, who purchased of the plaintiff certain supplies required in the construction of said road. The case was tried by the court without a jury, and very full findings of fact made and filed, of which the only portions we deem necessary for the purposes of this case may be briefly stated as follows: That Carroll & Donoghue, as co-partners, were sub-contractors under Fitzgerald & Bro., and were employed by them to perform the grading and excavating of certain sections of the road in the counties of Pennington and Dawrence; that plaintiff sold and delivered to said sub-contractors a quantity of blasting powder to be and which was used in the construction of said railroad by said sub-’on-tractors; that the reasonable value of the supplies so furnished was $844, no part of which has been paid; that at the time of the filing of plaintiff’s account or statement of lien there was no balance due from said Fitzgerald & Bro. to Carroll & Donoghue, but, on the contrary, said Carroll & Donaghue had been overpaid on said contract not less than $15,000. The court concluded as matter of law among other things, that, as there was no amount due from Fitzgerald & Bro. to Carroll & Donoghue when plaintiffs account of statement of lien was filed, and as it was not filed within 60 days after the materials were furnished, the plaintiff cannot avail itself of any benefits therefrom as against the defendant railroad, and its lien cannot be established in this action.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Congdon & Henry Hardware Co. v. Grand Island & W. C. R. Co.
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Where plaintiff, who furnishes supplies to a railroad subcontractor to be used in the construction of the road, fails to file his statement for a mechanic’s lien within sixty days, and the contractor fully pays the subcontractor, the statute does not entitle plaintiff to a mechanic’s lien against the railroad, though the company has not paid the contractor.