Sneed v. Mayfield's Heirs
Sneed v. Mayfield's Heirs
Opinion of the Court
delivered the following opinion of the Court:—
The pleadings in this case present the following statement: Southerland Mayfield, in his lifetime, to wit: on the 7th day of May, 1785, gave his
The first plea asserts that the plaintiff, or those under whom he claims, did not make claim within seven years after the decedent’s death, and therefore the claim is barred.
The Court in this cause, deem it unimportant to inquire whether the Act of 1715, referred to at the bar, intended to embrace demands against heirs or not. They will only say, that if it did, the Act of 1789 does not seem to repeal it as to heirs.
The substance of the fifth plea is that the transfer of the bond to John Mayfield, one of the heirs, extinguished the debt.
On the other side, it is insisted, that the heirs are not competent to plead this matter; that the Act of 1784, having provided that an heir may contest the truth of the plea of plene administravit, pleaded by an executor or administrator, implies that it was the meaning of the Legislature, no other matter should be brought into contest by the heir, on a scire facias, after the passage of the Act.
The Court dissent from this reasoning, and believe it to have been the intention of the Legislature not to have taken away any legal privileges which the heir possessed before. Lest it might be supposed that the heir would be concluded, by the finding of a jury, upon an issue joined between the claimant and the personal representative, the Legislature, to remove all doubt on that subject, enacted that the finding of no personal assets in a suit over which the heir had no control, shall not affect his rights. Res inter alios non nocet is not only a maxim of the common law,' but of the law of nature. On this ground, therefore, the plea was proper.
In relation to the matter of the plea we are of opinion it is sufficient to bar the plaintiff. When John Mayfield obtained the interest of this bond, he, together with his two brothers, were jointly liable to satisfy it.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- JAMES SNEED v. MAYFIELD'S HEIRS
- Status
- Published