Hearn v. Crutcher
Hearn v. Crutcher
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The principal question in this case is, whether Hearn is liable for more than the $97 00, due to Stone, after deducting the amount of the notes on Stone from the amount of moneys in Hearn’s hands belonging to Stone.
Hearn says that he had collected moneys as sheriff of Wilson county for Stone, and had paid him at various times $1050; that as stone and himself came to no settlement, he took Stone’s due bills for the sums paid him. The court is of opinion, that this statement shows that the money collected by Hearn, as sheriff, was paid to Stone; that the advances were intended by Hearn as a payment, and that the due bills were only taken as evidences of such payment, to be used by Hearn on a settlement as vouchers for him; for Hearn also states, that when he settled with Stone, he charged no interest on the notes. The reason he did not, must be, that he considered the moneys advanced at the date of each note, as being the payment of so much then due to Stone.
Hearn further states, that on the 28th of March, 1831, Stone enclosed to him a deed of trust, conveying certain
Stone evidently intended by the receipt, and the deed of trust, that Hearn should be indemnified for his advances out of the trust property, so that the fund derived from fees collected, should remain in Hearn’s hands protected from his. creditors, and to be appropriated to his own use. Hearn wras too honest to second his views in this; but having accepted the indemnity provided in the trust deed, the fund remains in his hands, not for Stone, but for his creditors.
The objection to the attachments which were-issued against Slone, is obviated by his appearance and confession of judgment. Having confessed a judgment in each of these cases, Stone cannot insist upon its reversal on
Hearn’s appearance and answer, is a waiver of any defect in the garnishee summons. Its office is ended so soon as the garnishee appears and submits to answer.
Let the judgment be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Hearn v. Crutcher and Bullard
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published