Clark v. Hunt's Lessee
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The question for the court to decide in this case, arises upon the charge of the court to the jury on the following entry, given in evidence as part of the plaintiff’s title:
“29th May, 1824, Stephen Clark enters a preference of 148 acres of land, lying in the county of Franklin, on the waters of Bradley’s creek of Elk river, beginning on a hickory, marked as a corner in the presence of Waller and Thomas Brixey, running south to the north boundary line of a 1000 acre tract, known in the name of Doherty’s heirs, thence west for complement.” The court charged the jury, that this entry was too vague and uncertain to enable the defendant (in the court below) to connect the same with his grant, and thereby overreach the grant of the plaintiff.
What are the objects called for: 1. A preference in Stephen Clark to enter this 148 acres. 2. It is in Frank
But the other calls must not be overlooked; the land is to lie on the waters of Bradley’s creek, to adjoin on the north boundary of Doherty, and extend west. If we say nothing of the hickory, still there is enough on the face óf the entry, take it all together, to fix the locality of the land. Transpose the language, to adjoin Doherty on the north boundary; lie on the waters of Bradley’s creek, and include the preference of the enterer. This would be giving such special notice of the land entered, as it is believed could not be mistaken by any one disposed to enter the same land. If the entry was prima facie good upon its face, and' no proofs be adduced to show that, nevertheless, it is uncertain, as by proving similar objects elsewhere, it must be available. The court there
Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.