Bradley v. Commissioners
Bradley v. Commissioners
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This bill is filed by the complainants, to enjoin the defendants from organizing the county of Powell, the establishment of which is directed by the act of 1839, ch. 192.
The 4th section of the 10th article of the constitution of the State, provides for the establishment of new counties, to consist of not less than three hundred and fifty square miles, and to contain not less than four hundred and fifty qualified voters.
The proof in the case shows conclusively, that the boundaries of the county do not contain the constitutional number of three hundred and fifty square miles, but much less; and the question is, whether the commissioners can be prohibited, by the decree of a court of chancery, from organizing the county contrary to the provisions of the constitution.
The convention of the State, which formed the constitution, thought proper to place restrictions upon the power of the legislature to establish new counties; and of consequence, any attempt to do so, contrary to the restrictions, is a void exercise of power, which can and must be stopped by the judicial department of the State. There is no other place to whichan appeal can be made,and if the courts cannot interfere, the constitution, if violated, is a dead letter.
But it is said, that the true remedy for this evil, is by writ of quo warranto and not by injunction.
To this we answer, if the courts have the power to remedy the evil, that remedy, which, under all the circumstances, will be most effectual, is the one which ought to be resorted to, if there is nothing in the mode of administering the law prohibiting it.
That the writ of quo warranto is the common law mode of re
It is submitted, whether one or two private individuals can seek the aid of a court of chancery for this purpose ?
We think that any person aggrieved, by the proceedings, may apply for the remedy.
Let the decree of the chancellor be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.