Elijah v. State
Elijah v. State
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The slave, Elijah, was convicted in the circuit Court of Smith county, for an assault and battery “upon David C. Puryear, being a free white person,” with intent to commit murder in the first degree. This indictment was framed upon the 10th section of the act of 1835, ch. 19, (Car. & Nich. 683,) which enacts, that “any slave or slaves who shall commit an assault and battery upon any feee white person, with intent to commit murder in the first degree, or a rape upon a free white woman, shall on conviction be punish
But, a fact that is essential should be laid in the indictment, and that constitutes the very gravamen of the charge, must also be proved. This is too plain a proposition to ■ admit of argument.— But it has been suggested, that the exhibition of Puryear, as a witness, was sufficient evidence that he was white and free.
If the fact be so, perhaps such exhibition of the person before the jury, would have made it unnecessary for any witness to be called on to swear that Puryear was a white person and free; but the fact must appear in the bill of exceptions, or we cannot know that it existed. Upon the strictest scrutiny, of the bill of exceptions, we are unable to detect any fact from which we can judicially infer that Puryear is a free white man. The name, as was said in Grandison’s case, imports nothing, for negroes have such names. Nor does his office of foreman in a mechanic’s shop, nor the fact that he was a witness in this cause, tend to prove whether he was black or white. Many negroes are conductors of mechanic shops, and several negro slaves were witnesses in this cause.
It would not do to say that we are not to presume, the jury would convict and the court would condemn the defendant, unless it had appeared, that the person he attempted to kill was a white man. The same argument might have been made in Ewell’s case. In that case, there was no evidence that the offence was committed in Bedford county.
As to the ground, which counsel has pressed upon the court, that the verdict was not justified by the proof in the cause, we think proper to express no opinion, as the judgment will be reversed upon another point, and we think it proper that the jury that may
See 6 Yerger, 376.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Elijah, a slave v. State
- Status
- Published