Applewhite v. Shaw
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The bill alledges, that the defendant A. T. Shaw was the
The bill prays, that the execution of said judgment be enjoined, and that said Ephraim be compelled to apply the property conveyed in said deed to the extinguishment of said judgment. To this bill there is a demurrer. We are of opinion, that the first endorser of a bill or note has no equity against the last endorser, who may take up such bill or note by reason of any security he may have obtained from the maker or drawer. He has a right to secure himself by taking a deed of trust or mortgage, and still to pursue his legal remedy against a prior endorser. But if he had actually received payment in whole or in part from the drawer, he would have no right to recover to that extent from the complainant. But if this were so, the complainant might have had an ample defence at law. If he did not make it, either from negligence in failing to get proof, or for want of proper pleas to the action, it is his misfortune. He cannot have a new trial here. Affirm the decree, and sustain the demurrer.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.