Smith v. White
Smith v. White
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
HughWhite sued JamesSmith before a Justice ofthePeace, and recovered judgment. Smith prayed an appeal on the day of trial, which was granted, upon his giving bond and security. This was not done at the time; but subsequently, viz, on the 2d day after the trial, he went to the Justice for the purpose of doing so, but met him going to church: he informed him of his business, and observed that if it would answer as well, he would attend and give the bond on the Monday following, it then being Saturday. To this the Justice replied, “well.” On the Monday following the Justice refused to receive the bond, alledging that it had not been tendered in time. Thereupon Smith filed a petition for a certiorari, in which a good legal de-fence to the action is shown, and the facts above stated are set forth as a reason for not having appealed. This petition was dismissed by the Circuit Court, to reverse which judgment this writ of error is prosecuted. We are of the opinion, that the judgment of the Circuit Court, dismissing the petition, is erroneous. We think the reason assigned for not giving the bond
Let the judgment be reversed, and this case be remanded for a trial upon its merits.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.