Russell v. Smith ex rel. Prince
Cases that cite this one
32 later published cases cite this decision. The 24 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Beneficial Hawaii, Inc. v. Kida (Haw. 2001)
- Haskin v. Greene (Or. 1955)
- Whitehouse v. Cargill (Me. 1896)
- Keller v. Ashford (Supreme Court of the United States 1890)
- Murrah v. State (Miss. 1875)
- State v. Thompson (La. 2001)
- Nixon v. Sirica (D.C. Cir. 1973)
- People v. Buthy (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1971)
- Nashville Trust Co. v. Grimes (Tenn. 1943)
- Maxwell v. Maxwell (New Jersey Court of Chancery 1937)
- Harms v. Cohen (District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania 1922)
- Bowers v. Bowers (New Jersey Court of Chancery 1919)
- Cross v. Buskirk-Rutledge Lumber Co. (Tenn. 1917)
- Gould v. Maine Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance (Me. 1916)
- Colonial Building & Loan Ass'n v. Griffin (New Jersey Court of Chancery 1915)
- Israel v. Day (Colo. App. 1902)
- Israel v. Day (Colo. App. 1902)
- Cincinnati, Hamilton & Dayton Railroad v. Bank (Ohio 1896)
- Hooper v. Hooper (Md. 1895)
- Olcott v. Gabert (Tex. 1893)
- Smith v. Lewis (La. 1893)
- State ex rel. Fair v. Frazier (Neb. 1890)
- Mathews v. Toogood (Neb. 1888)
- Burt v. Ambrose (Or. 1883)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Upon the above state of facts,
delivered the opinion of the court; deciding,
1. That the plaintiff, not being entitled to the possession of the covenant, the statement in the declaration is sufficient excuse for the failure to make profert of the instrument sued on.
2. The technical plea of payment, being irrelevant to an action of covenant, was properly stricken out. It is not enough that the facts of the plea meet the allegations of the declarations; it should also be technically relevant to the action.
3. The demurrer to the plea of set-off was well taken, because mutual debts can alone be pleaded as set-off; and because part of the matter pleaded is a claim for unliquidated damages for repairs done the premises, which claim is not the subject of set-off.
The judgment of the circuit court was, therefore, • affirmed.
Shelby v. Hearne, 6 Yerg. 512; Trezevant v. McNeal, 2 Humph. 352.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.