Powers v. Fitzhugh
Powers v. Fitzhugh
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
Fitzhugh held a note, under seal, executed to him by Powers, for fifteen dollars. The wife of Fitzhugh having
This suit was commenced by warrant before a justice of the peace, to recover the amount due upon said note, thus wrongfully paid to the wife of the plaintiff. The suit, however, is not brought upon the note; in the warrant, the defendant is summoned to answer the plaintiff in a plea of debt, due by account, under fifty dollars. The justice rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiff; and, on appeal to the circuit court by the defendant, the plaintiff again recovered judgment, from which an appeal in error is prosecuted to this court.
At the time of the trial before the justice, the plaintiff made and filed, with the warrant, an affidavit in substantial accordance "with the provision of the act of 1819, ch. 27, sec- 1, in which it is averred that Powers had fraudulently obtained the possession of said note.
The record contains a bill of exceptions setting forth the evidence; also exceptions to the opinion of the court in refusing to admit evidence offered by the defendant; and likewise the charge of the court; all which we deem it unnecessary to notice, as the determination of the case must rest upon a preliminary question, namely, whether the proper ground of recovery has not been altogether misconceived in this case.
The act of 1819, above referred to, which provides a remedy at law, where any bond, obligation, promissory
The profert, or production of the instrument is dispensed with, the affidavit being substituted instead thereof; but in all other respects the suit is to be conducted in the same manner and form as if the instrument were in the plaintiff’s possession. The present suit is not brought upon the note, as required by the statute; and there is no other ground upon which to maintain it. The plaintiff cannot resort to the original consideration of the note, because the simple contract was extinguished by the execution of a note under seal.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.