Smith v. Pearce
Smith v. Pearce
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
Wright, as executor of McCulloch, recovered a judgment by vconfession for five hundred and fifty dollars, for
The only question is, will an action of debt lie in such a case?
An administrator de bonis non, succeeds to all the rights, powers, and duties of his predecessor in the administration; 1 Wil. on Ex., 596. He steps into his shoes, and takes up the business of the estate where he left it. The duties and powers of such an administration, relate back to the death of the person of whom he is the second representative. He has all the rights and powers over the assets, which remain unadministered, that his predecessor had. • The duty and right to collect all the debts remaining uncollected, and not accounted for by the first administrator or executor, devolve upon him. This would apply to all choses in action of the deceased, whether in suit or not; and as well to judgments not collected, as to claims not sued upon. The only question is, are such notes, claims or judgments, assets of the estate represented by the latter administrator? If so, he has a right to recover them; 1 Chitty’s PL, 22. The principle is so far extended, as that an administrator de bonis non can sue on a promise made to a former administrator, 'and he may join counts or promises made to their intestate.
Debt will lie upon a judgment. 1 Chitty’s Pl. 111, 370.
There was, perhaps, no other way by which a judgment in favor of an administrator, who died before its collection, could be enforced by an administrator de bonis non, but to sue upon it, until act of 1851, ch. 20, gave the writ of scire facias. What more cheap and summary remedy might have been resorted to in this case by the plaintiff? But that statute does not take away the common law right of suing, but is merely cumulative, and the party may adopt either; 3 Greenl. 303. It is no ground of complaint by defendant, that the more dilatory mode of proceeding has been adopted by the plaintiff.
We therefore reverse the judgment below, sustaining
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Smith, adm'r. v. Pearce
- Status
- Published