Worley v. Waldran
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is an action o-f debt, against Worley as masker, and Richardson as endorser of a promissory ¡note. The declaration is in the ordinary form, and the plea of nil debit is put in by Richardson, the endorser, «pon which the plaintiff took issue. Judgment by default was .at the same time taken against Worley, and .a writ of enquiry ordered. At the next term, a jury was sworn, “ to enquire of and assess the
The plaintiff then introduced as a witness, W. A. Rose, who testified that said certificate “ was in his-hand-writing; ” that he was at that time clerk of the notary, and it was his business to deliver notices of protest; that it was his habit to make such entries at the time of delivering the notices; that he had no-recollection. of having, given notice of protest to Richardson the endorser; but from the fact of seeing his endorsement to that effect, on the protest, he presumed he had, and was satisfied in his own mind that he had given the notice as stated in his certificate on the protest
To all of this testimony, the defendant objected;, the objection was overruled by the Court, which is now assigned, and relied on here, as error. We will consider first, the question of variance. The note sued
Had the defendant proved that there was also a Union Bank there, then he would have raised a more difficult, and perhaps, a fatal objection; but in the absence of such proof, we must take as prima facie true, the certificate of the Notary, that he presented the note for payment “ at the branch of the Union Bank, it being payable at said Bank.”
The objection taken to the pai’ol testimony of W. A. Rose, we think is equally untenable. The witness stated that “ he had no recollection of having given notice of protest to Richardson, the endorser, but from the fact of seeing his endorsement, to that effect, on the protest, he presumed he had.” Had the witness stepped here, his testimony would perhaps have been incompetent. 5 Wendell, 301; 1 Starkie Ev. 129; 1 Philips Ev. 289; 8 East 284-9, and other authorities. But the witness proceeds and says, he is “ satisfied in-Ms own mind, that he had given the notice as stated in his certificate on the protest.” This testimony is-
Where an agent made a parol lease, and entered a memorandum of its terms in a book, which was produced, but the witness stated that he had no memory of the transaction hut from the hook, without which he should not of his own knowledge he able to speak to the fact, hut on reading the entry he had no douht that the fact really happenedthe testimony was held competent.—1 Gr’f. Ev. 437, and numerous authorities there cited.
It often occurs that subscribing witnesses are called to prove the execution of deeds and other instruments, who have no recollection of seeing the paper executed but from the fact of seeing their names as subscribing witnesses, in their own hand-writing, and being satisfied that they would not have put them there if they had not seen the paper executed, such evidence has always been regarded as competent and sufficient.
The only remaining question is, that the jury “found the issue in favor of the plaintiff, and assessed the plaintiff’s damages to $16.27,” upon which the Court gave judgment against both defendants for the debt, in the declaration mentioned, and the damages by the jury assessed; when, as it is insisted, the Court should have given judgment only for the amount found by the jury. This objection is not tenable.
The judgment by default against Worley authorized the Court to render judgment final against him for the .amount of the debt, and the damages, which was 'a
We therefore think, there is no error in the record, and affirm the judgment.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.