Carren v. Breed
Carren v. Breed
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
In this case, it appears that John Carren, F. Shu-holdt, and S. J. Crothers, brought their action in the Circuit. Court of Montgomery, against Samuel Simpson, to recover one thousand- dollars, due by bond; and that the action was successfully prosecuted to final judgment. At the time the suit was instituted, the ordinary prosecution bond was executed, with A. Robb, (now dead,) and James E. Bailey, security for costs. Execution issued on the judgment, which was duly returned, indorsed, “No property found to make the debt, or any part thereof;” whereupon the Clerk, the plaintiff in this case, moved the Court for judgment against the defendants in error, and their securities in the prosecution bond, for the fees due him on account of services rendered, at the instance of plaintiffs in the original action. The Circuit Judge allowed the motion, and proceeded to pronounce judgment for $6.25 against the plaintiffs, and James E. Bailey, and Mary E. Robb, Executrix of A. Robb, deceased; from which the latter two, as sureties in the prosecution bond, appeal in error to this Court.
The rule of the common law, that witnesses. shall be tendered their fees before they are bound to' attend, has been, for many years, abrogated by Statute in this
In cases of witnesses, as far back as Martin & Yerger's Reports, 38, 43, it was held, and the rule has been adhered to ever since, that a witness might maintain his action against tfife party,. and at whose instance he was summoned, at the end of every term; and that he was not bound to wait the termination of the cause, in which he gave his evidence as a witness. But no case, of which we. are aware, under our practice, has gone so far as to authorize the Clerk to .recover his fees, by suit, before the termination of the cause in which the services were rendered. The practice has been the reverse. But it is clear, upon principles of common law, as well as by the Statute, a Clerk can, if the unsuccessful party is unable, . after judgment against him, to pay the fees due, maintain his action
The judgment of the Circuit Court must be reversed; and the motion, as to the sureties in the prosecution bond, disallowed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Carrens. v. J. C. Breed, Clerk
- Status
- Published