Waldraven v. Mayor of Memphis
Waldraven v. Mayor of Memphis
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This hill was filed in the Chancery Court at Memphis, against the Mayor and Aldermen, to enjoin and restrain them from the repeal of an ordinance, under which he, (the complainant,) was elected Chief of' the Fire Department, for the 40th year of the corporation of the City of Memphis, beginning in June, 1866, and ending in June, 1867. He states he was legally inducted into office, and that he has satisfactorily discharged the duties thereof up to the filing of this hill.
The Board of Mayor and Aldermen sought to remove him, by electing another, and went through the forms of an election. This was without cause on his part. They were enjoined from this proceeding — the Court determining this was void. They then sought to accomplish their purpose by abolishing the office, to defeat complainant of his rights and to effect his dismissal. An ordinance has been introduced, and passed the first reading of the board, and will become a law of the corporation, unless restrained by the action of the Court. That this is a violation of law and the rights of the complainant, as the office is worth $250 per month. An injunction was prayed for and granted. The defendants demurred to the bill, and for cause of demurrer, assigned the following: The office of Chief of Fire Department, is an office created by an ordinance of the City of Memphis, and can be repealed by an ordinance of the same board. Secondly, an officer elected to an office, has no such right in an office as to make it a vested right, so as to prevent the abolition of said of
The only question presented for our consideration, is: When the power is vested in a corporation, to pass an ordinance creating an office, can they repeal the ordinance, after it is filled by an election of the board, before the expiration of the time for which the incumbent was elected? By the 5th sec. of article 2d, of the City Charter, it is provided, there shall be such other officers and agents of the corporation, as may be provided by ordinance, to be elected by the Board of Mayor and Aldermen, and to perform such duties as may be prescribed by ordinance. Under this section, an ordinance was passed, creating the office of Chief of Fire Department. It was provided, he should be elected annually, upon the nomination of the Mayor, unless sooner removed by the Board; that he should hold his office during the corporate year in which he is elected, and until his successor is elected and qualified. He shall give bond, etc.: 1st Sec., Art. 1st, Chap. 4th, Bridges’ Digest, 122. The other sections of the article define the duties of the officer, etc. The powers of a corporation are derived from its charter. This instrument creates it an artificial being; it is the fundamental law, and is, in its terms and spirit, as a Constitution to the petty legislature of the body acting by and under it. The power being given, under the charter, to create, by ordinance, such offices as may be necessary to carry into effect the purposes of a corpo
It follows, therefore, the Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Memphis, having the power, under the provisions of their charter, to create, by ordinance, the office which the complainant had been elected to fill, have the right to repeal the ordinance creating it.
There is no error in the decree of the Chancellor, and it will be affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- M. E. Waldraven v. Mayor & Aldermen of Memphis
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published