Coward v. Thompson
Coward v. Thompson
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a suit commenced before a Justice. The action is founded on a note fer $200, executed by the defendant to the plaintiff, on 31st December, 1864, and due December 25th, 1865. A judgment was rendered against defendant, for debt and interest; from which, he appealed to the Circuit Court. The cause was tried before a jury, and, under the instructions of the Court, a judgment was rendered against the defendant for $27;
The only question upon this record, arises upon the instructions of the Judge to the jury, which are substantially as follows: “By the amendments to the Constitution of the State, abolishing slavery, adopted on the 22d of February, 1865, the plaintiff no longer held a specific property in the slave, and the defendant was no longer bailee of plaintiff. The fact of the slave having been freed by the act of the Government, the consideration for which the note was given, failed, and the defendant’s liability ought to cease, after the plaintiff ceased to have a specific property in the slave. Therefore, the plaintiff was only entitled to recover for the timé he had possession, which the Court held to terminate on 22d February, 1865.”
By the adoption of the amendments to the Constitution of the State, on the 22d of February, 1865, slavery, or involuntary servitude, ceased to exist in the State; the right of property in slaves ceased; and the consequence of which was, the loss fell upon the owner.
A hirer of a slave for the year, was the temporary owner for the period of hiring. This is, and has been, the settled doctrine of this Court, as enunciated in many well considered cases: Horsely vs. Branch, 1 Humph., 199; 9 Yerger, 45.
The judgment will be reversed, and a new trial awarded; in which the law will be charged in conformity with the principles settled in this opinion.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- William Coward v. Samuel A. Thompson
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published