Sharp v. Treece
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The judgment of the Circuit Court must be reversed, for error in the Court, in overruling the motion for a new trial.
An action of trespass was commenced and prosecuted in the Circuit Court of Claiborne county, by the defendant in error, against the plaintiff in error, for seizing and taking of the property of the plaintiff, fifteen hundred pounds of sugar.
On the trial, the defendant in error introduced, as a witness, John McCrary, who stated, “that witness, defendant and others, were staying all night at Smith Seals’. All the party went out to the barn or stable, except defendant and witness, and we did not go out. While we were sitting together by the fire, defendant told me he had had the plaintiff’s property taken;, that he, the defendant, went along most of the way, but stopped a little short, but in sight of the place where the goods were taken, and then returned with the soldiers; and that his son went with the wagon and got the sugar. The circumstance began by my running down the plaintff, and letting on that I was a rebel. Defendant told me that he bought some sugar of the soldiers, and got some work done for it; and also, that they sold to other neighbors near them. Plaintiff never got me to ask defendant about the matter.”
There was verdict and judgment for defendant in error. A motion for a new trial was overruled.
In support of his motion, the plaintiff in error read his own affidavit, in which he states “he was wholly
The affidavit of Richard Burk was also read in support of the motion, and corroborates, in every pai’-ticular, that of Sharp, stating further, that he has no recollection of being out of the company of Sharp that night at any time.
Taking these affidavits as true, which we must do on a motion for a new trial, the Court should have granted it.
It is clear, from these affidavits, that the plaintiff in error was surprised by the testimony of McCrary, and that he could not have been prepared to meet it.
It appears probable, from the whole case, that if the evidence of Richard Burk had been before a jury, a different verdict would have been rendered. Therefore a new trial should have been granted. 3 Hum., 223-4.
In the examination of the testimony, Alfred Fletcher, a witness, stated, in response to a question of the Court, “ the defendant was acting with the rebels, and the plaintiff was a Union man.”
As a general rule, and a safe one, it is the province of a Court presiding over jury trials to try causes as presented by parties or their attorneys; to administer the law as' they, by their pleadings and proof, develop it; at no time performing the olflce of an attorney.
Judgment reversed and cause remanded.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.