State v. Withers
State v. Withers
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The defendant was indicted in the Criminal Court of Davidson county for an assumed violation of sec. 4819 of the Code, providing that it shall be a misdemeanor “ for any person falsely to assume to be a judge, a justice of the peace, sheriff, or other judicial or ministerial officer, and take upon himself to act as such, or to require anyone to aid or assist him in any matter pertaining to the duty of any such officer.
Defendant was convicted and fined fifty cents. A motion for a new trial and in arrest of judgment was made, which was overruled, and an appeal in error prosecuted to this court.
It is obvious that these facts do not constitute the offense created by the statute. The party did not personate a sheriff, or constable, or any ministerial officer of the State, but claimed to be, what he was in fact, a detective of the city, and only misconstrued his powers as such detective. While he might- have been liable for the trespass in making or attempting the arrest without authority of law, yet it cannot be said he falsely assumed to be any officer named or intended to be included in sec. 4819. He was what he assumed to be, but went beyond his authority in that petition. The count must be reversed for these reasons.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- State v. Wash Withers
- Status
- Published