Kay v. Smith
Kay v. Smith
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The only question necessary to be considered is whether the proof shows that the complainants began their suit within one year, as prescribed by the statute, from the time the work was finished.
James Genette testified that from June, 1859, to July, 1860, he was engaged doing carpenter’s work on the house for Smith, “and saw complainants and those employed by them doing the plastering and stuccoing on said building.”
Geo. M. Grant says he was building for Smith from June, 1859, to July, 1860, and saw complainants at the same time plastering, etc.
Henry Nolen says that in the fall of 1859, and spring of 1860, he did the painting on the house, aud during that time saw complainants engaged in plastering the house, etc. Witness quit before the painting was finished, and when he quit the plastering, etc., was all done.”
In 1 Col., 528, 529, the court say the mechanic’s lien is' a peculiar one, and must be taken strictly, and it is incumbent upon complainant to make out a case clearly within the provisions of the statute. The
Testing the case now under consideration by the rule laid down in the case first cited, we are of opinion that complainants have failed to show clearly that their bill was filed within one year from the completion of the work. The testimony of neither Grant nor Genette shows clearly and satisfactorily that complainants were engaged in plastering during the whole time from June, 1859, to July, 1860. They state that they were at work during the period specified, and that they saw complainants at work there also, but do not state when complainants finishéd their work,
In this state of the proof, and there is no other upon this point, we are constrained to hold that it ,i,s not shown by that clear and satisfactory evidence which is required, that the bill was filed within one year from the time at which the work was finished. For this reason we reverse the decree of the Chancellor and dismiss the bill.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.