Motions v. Curry
Motions v. Curry
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
At the present term, judgments have been taken against Curry, late Sheriff of Shelby County, in favor of the clerk of this court, and in favor of the State,— for failure to return executions, — for costs and State and county taxes.
A question is now presented, whether, in the taxation of the costs of the judgments, the State tax upon suits should be included. In the case of the State v. Allison, 2 Swan, 373, where the Circuit Judge excluded the State tax from the bill of costs, upon appeal to this court it was held that a motion against a. sheriff for an insufficient return of an execution, was a suit or action; and that, under the act of
Code, sec. 551, provides that the unsuccessful party in every litigation in the courts of record shall pay a State tax. The act of 1870, 2d sess., eh. 26, sec. 1 (Thompson & Steger’s Statutes, sec. 553, a, sub-sees. 19-23), designates the rate of taxation, and specifies the kinds of litigation to be taxed:—
1. Original suits in any of the courts of law or equity.
2. Petitions for distribution of estates.
3. Appeals, writs of error, or of certiorari, to the supreme court.
4. Appeals or writs of certiorari from a justice of' the peace.
5. Upon each presentment or indictment.
We have repeatedly held that a motion is, in legal' effect, a suit or action; and in State v. Allison, it is. said to be a substitute for the common law action on the case. In Merritt v. Parks, 6 Hum., 333, the court said that the motion was, in substance, an action of debt. And so a motion is, and may be properly said to be, an action on the case, or an action of debt, in a proper ease for such form of action, and in a .tribunal having jurisdiction to try an original action of debt or case.
But the motion may be used, not merely as a substitute for an original suit of debt or ease, but as a means of enforcing the execution of a judgment already rendered. And it is upon this ground alone
The result is, that, in making out the bills of costs in these several judgments, no State tax will be included in the bills of costs.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.