Farrell v. Ætna Fire Insurance
Farrell v. Ætna Fire Insurance
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The action is upon a policy of insurance against fire, and the trial resulted in a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff below for $3,500 and interest. The insurance was upon the plaintiff’s building in the city of Jackson, the value thereof, as stated in the policy, being $3,500.
Among the preliminary and supplementary proofs required by the contract of insurance to be furnished the underwriters in the event of loss was the certificate of a justice of the peace that the loss had been sustained without fraud or fault on the part óf the assured. This certificate states the value of the property at $3,500, and the same was produced and read to the jury.
The defendant asked the court to instruct the jury that- this certificate would only be looked to by the jury to show that the plaintiff had complied with the conditions of the policy, which required the certificate of the nearest magistrate to be furnished the company as to the fact that the property had been destroyed by fire, and that it was the result of misfortune, and not the act of the plaintiff.
These instructions the court declined to give, and in this we hold there was no error. The proof in the cause shows that the estimate of value, as stated in the preliminary proofs, and as adopted in the justice’s certificate, was considerably in excess of the real
Reverse the judgment and award a new trial.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.