Clifford v. State
Clifford v. State
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court;
The prisoner was convicted of the crime of horse-stealing, and has appealed from the judgment.
The first error assigned is that the court sustained a demurrer to his plea in abatement. This plea avers that four of t-he grand jury who found the indictment, and whose names are given, were not at the time legally qualified to act as such in this, that they were not before the finding of said indictment charged by the court touching their duties.
An indictment found by a grand jury, when part of the jurors are not legally qualified to' act as such, may he abated upon the plea of the defendant. And it is also true that the statute requires that the jury, after being empaneled and sworn, shall he charged. Code, 5076.
Upon the trial the defendant examined one Olaywell as a witness in his behalf, and his testimony, if true, was important. Upon cross-examination, the attorney-general asked the witness if he had not been charged with murder, which was objected to, and the objection sustained, but the court said the attorney-general might show the fact by the record. The witness was also asked upon what charge he was put in jail. This was objected to, and the objection sustained, but the court said the attorney-general might show by the record, and thereupon the attorney-general read an indictment against the witness for larceny, to which objection was made. The court said to the jury that they might look at the indictment and other charges as circumstances bearing upon the credit of the witness, but not for the purpose of showing that the witness was guilty of the charges because he stood indicted.
We are constrained to hold that this was error. The
There are many other questions in the record which have been earnestly argued, but we think it unnécessary to express any opinion in regard to them, as the judgment must be reversed on the ground stated.
Let the judgment be reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- JOHN CLIFFORD v. State
- Status
- Published