Hogan v. Mayor of Chattanooga
Hogan v. Mayor of Chattanooga
Opinion of the Court
delivered tire opinion of tire court:
Ilogan obtained writs of certiorari and supersedeas to bring up and quasb a judgment of tlie recorder of the city assessing a fine of $50, and thirty days imprisonment, for the violation of a city ordinance and the laws of the state.
The writs were returned executed, hut the transcript shows no record or papers of any character from the recorder’s court. A motion to quash the proceedings was made and overruled, and the cause then tried by the judge, a jury being waived, and the judgment of the recorder affirmed. Hogan has appealed.
Justices of the peace and recorders of towns have such original criminal jurisdiction as is expressly conferred by law. Code, sec. 4966 [Shannon’s Code, sec. 6927]. Misdemeanors are not within the meaning of the fourteenth clause of the bill of rights [Con., art. 1, sec. 14], ordaining that no person shall be put to answer any criminal charge but by presentment, indictment, or impeachment (McGinnis v. The State, 9 Hum., 43), nor within the clause ordaining that the right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate (Trigally v. Mayor and Aldermen of Memphis, 6 Cold., 382). So the recorder would not be precluded by these provisions from trying the defendant for violating the laws of the state, in such cases as by law he is vested with jurisdiction.
But we do not find, that he is vested with criminal jurisdiction to try offenses against the state, except concurrently with justices of the peace. See sec. 11 of charter, acts of 1869, p. 169. This would be to assess fines in certain cases of'submission, or require the defendant to enter into bond for his appearance at court.
But aside from this, penalties prescribed by ordinances •of the city may be recovered by suit, in the nature of an .action of debt, if the ordinance be in accordance with the
The judgment must be reversed, and the judgment of the recorder quashed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- ED. HOGAN v. MAYOR AND ALDERMEN OF CHATTANOOGA
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published