East Tennessee, Virginia & Georgia Railroad v. Hamblen County
East Tennessee, Virginia & Georgia Railroad v. Hamblen County
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court:
This case was submitted to the circuit court of Hamblen county upou an agreed state of facts, and involves the question whether the railroad extending from Morristown to Wolf Creek is subject to 'taxation. The entire road, with its franchises, was purchased by the present owners under a sale made in virtue of proceedings had in the chancery court at Nashville, for the sale of delinquent railroads, and it is claimed that the entire road, with its appurtenances, etc., was exempt from taxation in the hands of the original company, and that the exemption still attaches to the property in the hands of the present owners.
The road was originally constructed and owned by a corporation styled “The Cincinnati, Cumberland Gap & Charleston Railroad Company.” The charter of this company was granted in act of the legislature of the 18th of November, 1853 [Acts 1853-4, ch. 301]. Previously, on the 9th of February, 1850, the legislature had passed an act [Acts 1849-50, ch. 76] chartering the Nashville & Louisville Railroad Company, and, by the fortieth section, it is provided that the capital stock, dividends, roads, fixtures, depots, workshops, warehouses, and vehicles of transportation should be exempt from taxation, with certain provisos not important now to consider. The eighth section of the charter of the Cincinnati, Cumberland Gap & Charleston Railroad Company, provides “that said company shall be, and they are hereby, vested with all the rights, powers, and privileges, and subject to all the restrictions and liabilities, of the Nashville & Louisville Railroad Company, except otherwise provided for in this charter.” It is by virtue of this section that the exemption is claimed, and the question is whether the exemption granted to the' Nashville & Louisville Company was granted to the Cincinnati, Cum-
We place our decision of the case upon this ground without noticing other questions.
The judgment will be affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- THE EAST TENNESSEE, VIRGINIA & GEORGIA RAILROAD CO. v. HAMBLEN COUNTY
- Status
- Published