This ease was affirmed in the supreme court of the United States. 103 U. S., 417 (L. ed., Book 26, 401). It was criticised and distinguished in Tennessee v. Whitworth, 117 U. S., 139 (L. ed., Book 29, 833, 835, 836). It was cited in 7 Lea, 665; 12 Lea, 592; 13 Lea, 405; 16 Lea, 122; 7 Pickle, 562, 571, 572, 579, 590. The opinion in this case in the chancery court was published in 3 Tenn. Chy., 597, and was cited in 9 Lea, 613, 614.