Gardner v. Lewis
Gardner v. Lewis
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
By the agreed state of facts in this case, it ap
By the act of 1867-8, ch. 79, sec. 5, clause 8 (T. & S. Rev., sec. 553a, sub-sec. 38), it is provided, “ Each express wagon or cart, including wagons or carts engaged in transferring, other than those belonging to express or omnibus companies, shall take out a license annually from the county court clerk, and shall pay a tax for each express wagon five dollars, each express cart .five dollars, each transfer wagon (two horse) ten dollars, each transfer wagon (four horse) fifteen dollars.”
By the act of 1868 — 9, ch. 45, sec. 3 (T. & S. Rev., sec. 553a, sub-sec. 39), it is provided, “So much of the said act of March 13, 1868, as refers to express wagons, transfer wagons and carts, shall not be
Again, by the act of 1869, ch. 30 (T. & S. Rev., sec. 553a, sub-sec. 40), it is enacted, “That an' act to amend the revenue laws of this State, passed on the 13th of March, 1868, shall not be so construed as to compel persons to pay tax on farm wagons, or such wagons as are used promiscuously as farm wagons, and no such wagons shall be known as transfer wagons, as denominated in said law.”
Once more, by the act of 1870, ch. 94 (T. & S. Rev., sec. 553a, sub-sec. 41), it is provided, “That so "much of the acts passed the 13th of March, 1868, and February 19, 1869, as imposes a tax on wagons hauling corn, hay, oats, fodder, wood, ore, coal, or pig iron, be and the same is hereby repealed.”
The act of 1879, ch. 97, sec. 1, is: “That sub-sec. 38 of sec. 553a, of Thompson & Steger’s edition of the Code, which imposes a privilege tax on express wagons, express carts, and transfer wagons, be and the same is hereby so amended as to read: For wagons, drays, and all other vehicles drawn by one horse, one dollar; two horses, two dollars, and one dollar for each additional horse used, except for those used for farm wagons, and by the original vendor, or producer of ,the products of the soil or dairy, raised or produced by himself.”
“ Sec. 2. That sub-sec. 41 of sec. . 553a of the Code be and the same is hereby so amended as to -strike out of said section coal and pig iron.”
In this view the judgment of the criminal court in favor of Gardner is correct, and must be affirmed, with costs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- W. T. Gardner v. J. F. J. Lewis, County Court Clerk
- Status
- Published