Brady v. State
Brady v. State
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
By the act of 1865, chapter 15 (new Code, section 2359), it is made “the duty of every person who shall sell, or be authorized to sell tickets to passenger's to travel on any railroad in this State, at any station or depot within the State, to open his office for the sale of tickets at least one hour before the time for the departure of each passenger train from each station or depot, and keep the same open during said space óf one hour, and until the departure of each passenger train, and be always ready during said time to sell tickets to passengers as they may, during said hour, apply for them.” A failure to comply strictly with
The plaintiff in error was indicted by the attorney-general ex officio, by order of the court, for unlawfully failing to open and keep open the ticket office at Fountain Head, a way station on the Louisville & Nashville railroad, of which station he was the ticket agent, for one hour before the departure of the passenger train on a' particular morning. The judge tried the case without a jury, and found the defendant guilty. He has appealed in error.
Fountain Head is a way station on the Louisville & Nashville railroad, at which all of the trains stop except the fast express train. The defendant is the sole agent of the railroad company at that station, being ticket agent, freight agent and telegraph operator. He sells tickets for the various passenger trains which stop at that station. But, in view of his various •duties, he is not required by the rules of the company to open the ticket office for the morning accommodation train, which passes the station before six o’clock, but is excused from so doing. The railroad company, in consequence thereof, instructs the conductors running that train not to charge passengers any other rate than the regular ticket rate, and passengers by that train are permitted to pay the same fare on the train as they would pay for tickets. The proof shows that this was not a new arrangement at the time alleged in the indictment, but had been in force for a, year or more. It is further shown that on the
The proof is, therefore, clear that the ticket office was not opened as required by the terms of the statute. It is equally clear that the railroad company, by its rules, had dispensed with the sale of tickets for the train in question, and had provided that the passengers might pay their fare after entering the cars at the same rate as if they had pui’chased tickets,, and that these rules had been in force for a sufficient length of time to become known to the public. And the question is whether these facts constituted a defense to the indictment.
Of course, it would not be in fhe power of the-compauy by any rules it might adopt to dispense with, a compliance upon the part of its officers with a general law of the Legislature regulating the performance of a public duty intended for the benefit of passengers on the company's trains, if the law were within the competency of the Legislature. And no argument has been submitted tending to show that the statute in question was not within the police power of the State. The only ground upon which the defense relied on can be made is, that the facts do not bring the defendant within- the purview of the law having in view the object of its passage, the evil intended to be remedied, and the real intention of the Legislature. And the question is one of grave difficulty.
Railroad companies, we know as matter of current
If the defendant was a regular ticket seller, required to sell tickets for all the passenger trains which stopped at his station, and passengers who got on the trains at the station were mulcted in a penalty for failing to buy tickets in advance, the defendant would be guilty under the statute beyond all doubt, and the
The facts do, therefore, make out a good defense, and the judgment of the trial court must be reversed, and judgment rendered' here for the defendant.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Ed. Brady v. State
- Status
- Published