Railroad v. Bigbee
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Southern Railway Co. v. Forrest (Tenn. Ct. App. 1931)
- Louisville & Nashville R. R. v. Timmons (Tenn. 1905)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
These two separate cases involve the duties of a railroad company to erect and maintain stock gaps and wing fences where the road passes through or by the inclosed lands and fields of another. Bigbee owns a parcel of land lying on both sides of the railroad. On the east side he and the railroad company have erected a fence parallel with the road, and about thirty feet from it, and the space between his fence and the railroad track on this side is a deep ditch or gully, so that it is unfit for cultivation or any other ordinary use.
Bryan owns a parcel lying between Bigbee’s two tracts, coming up to the railroad on the west side, but not crossing it. Where the road enters and leaves Bigbee’s land a stock gap and wing fences are erected, and as to these there is no controversy. There is also a stock gap and wing fence between Bigbee and Bryan on their north partition line on the west side of the road, but the wing fence is defective. There was also a stock gap and wing fence on their south partition line, on the west side of the road, but that fence, having been taken down for the purpose of replacing it with a new one, the road filled up its stock pit and declines to erect or maintain it or wing fences at that point. Hogs and cattle have passed through the wing fences between Bryan and Bigbee, and caused damage to each.
We are of opinion that it is the duty of the railroad company to maintain pits and cattle guards where it enters the premises of Bigbee and where
We are not satisfied with the reasoning or authority of this case as applied to the case now being-considered. In this case, the railroad has an easement for right of way over one hundred feet on each side of the center line of its track. But it can occupy only so much of this as is necessary for its purposes, which are ordinarily for its track, roadway, cuts, and embankments. Up to this line, the
The Bigbee case was tried by the Court without a jury, and the Bryan case with a jury. The judgment in favor of the plaintiffs for damages must, in each case, be reversed. In the Bigbee case, the proof showing that the stock which caused the damage passed through the wing fences, and not over the track and cattle guard, and, there being no obligation on the road to maintain the wing fences, this
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.