Sibley v. State
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Tennessee Conservation League v. Cody (Tenn. 1987)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The defendent (Sibley) is General Manager of the Watauga Lumber Company, a corporation constructing booms and doing business on the Watauga River, in Carter County and elsewhere. He is convicted of a violation of the Act of March 3, 1899. This Act is as follows:
“ Section 1. Be it enacted Toy the General As-senibly of the State of Tennessee, That no person, firm, or corporation shall hereafter erect or. build any dam or other obstruction across the waters of the Watauga River in Carter County, so as to prevent the free passage of fish up and down the waters of the same.
“Sec. 2. Be it further enacted, That all persons, firms, or corporations now owning or using any such dam or obstructions, whether for the purpose of booms or other use, shall immediately provide a sluice or waterway, not less than ten feet in width and five feet in depth of water, such sluice or waterway to be in and upon the natural bed of the river, or so cut and constructed as to make such flow or waterway upon the ground adjacent to such dam and natural bed of the river, for the free, easy, and unobstructed passage of fish up and down the waters of the same, which said way shall be kept open at all seasons of the year.”
The Court charged the jury, that if there was a waterway that afforded a reasonably free and easy passage for fish up and down the stream at at any and all seasons, then the Legislative requirer ment would be met, and the defendant would not be guilty, but if no such way was provided, and by reason thereof, fish were prevented from passing at any season, defendant would be guilty as charged.
Two assignments on the merits are made, one, that the evidence does not support the verdict, and the other, that the Act is unconstitutional.
While there is some conflict of evidence we think the case is made out that the passage of fish up and down the stream is materially interfered with by the dam, and that no sufficient passageway, as contemplated by the Act, is provided.
The proper construction of the constitutional provision is, however, a matter of much importance. It will be seen that the Constitution authorizes the Legislature to enact laws for the protection and preservation of fish and game, etc. Under this provision the Legislature has from time to time, and frequently, passed laws against the killing of game in certain seasons, and the taking of fish by traps, nets or seines, or their destruction by poison or dynamite; and all such laws seem appropriately to be in furtherance and accordance with the provision to protect and preserve game and fish. But it is difficult to see how this Act tends to protect and preserve fish. The existence of a dam or of a passageway does not tend to protect or preserve
It cannot be that the Legislature, under this constitutional provision, can authorize the cutting of these dams, which would result in the practical destruction of many of the plants in order that fish may have the liberty of the streams and be unimpeded in passing up and down them, when such passage is not shown in any way to be necessary or essential to their protection and preservation. There is ample scope for the operation of the provision without so construing it as to authorize the
We are of opinion that the Act in question is not authorized by the constitutional provision relied on, and that it is obnoxious to the Constitution and void because in conflict with Sec. 8 of Art. 1, and is partial, and not the law of the land. There was a demurrer to the indictment, which does not not appear to have been acted upon. There was also a motion in arrest of judgment. Each of these should properly have been sustained and the indictment quashed.
The judgment of the Court below is reversed, and indictment quashed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.