Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 1880

Haines v. State

Haines v. State
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided July 1, 1880 · Winkler
9 Tex. Ct. App. 410

Haines v. State

Opinion of the Court

Winkler, J.

The indictment upon which the appellant was tried and convicted charges him and another with the murder of one negro child (the name and sex and a better description of said negro child being to the grand jurors unknown), alleged to have been committed in Panola County, on August 10, 1867. It was developed on the trial that the defendant and the other person charged with the murder in the indictment were the grandfather and grandmother of the child alleged to have been murdered, and that the mother of the child was the daughter of the defendant and his wife. There is but one bill of exceptions in the record. This relates to the admission of evidence over objection by the defendant, but we are unable to determine whether there was error or not in the ruling, for the reason that the bill of exceptions does not state the evidence to which the objection applies, in any other way than by a reference to some other portion of the record, — as, for instance, to the statement of facts, — and here we are met with the difficulty *412that there is no such statement of facts in the record as we can, under established rules of practice, consider. As presented in the transcript before us, the paper purporting to be a statement of facts is without the approval of the judge who presided at the trial. This is indispensable, agreeably to the whole current of decisions in Texas.

Considering, then, such matters as are properly presented for revision, and finding a proper indictment and charge of the court, and finding no error in the proceedings so presented as that they can be inquired into, the judgment is affirmed.

Affirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.