G. H. & S. A. R. R. v. Davis
G. H. & S. A. R. R. v. Davis
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
§ 147. Damages for hilling animal; market value the measure; rule where there is no market. The general rule is that the true test of the value of a thing is .what it will bring in market. [R. R. Co. v. Buckley, 1 vol. T. L. J. p. 283.] But to constitute market value it must appear that similar things have been bought and sold in the way of trade in sufficient quantity or frequency to establish a market value for such things. Where there is no market value for the thing, its value must then be ascertained by the circumstances of the case — the intrinsic value of the
§ 148. Exemplary damages; railroad company not subject to, for malicious acts of its servants, unless, etc. Although the killing of an animal be the wanton, wicked and malicious act of the engineer or other employee of a railroad company, the company will not be liable for exemplary damages unless it authorized or approved the act. [Hays v. R. R. Co. 46 Tex. 281.]
§ 149. Railroad company; liability for stock killed, etc. Our statute [Pas. Dig. art. 4926; R. S. art. 4245] defines the liability of railroad companies in respect to stock killed by their cars or locomotives. It makes the company liable to the owner for the value of all stock killed or injured, and this without regard to the degree of care or negligence which may have attended it, absolutely and at all events, where the company has not fenced in its road. [R. R. Co. v. Muldrow, 54 Tex. 233.]
Eeversed and remanded.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.