Henson & Cumming v. Flannigan
Henson & Cumming v. Flannigan
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
§ 566. Futures; dealing in, is gambling; contract for, is illegal and cannot be enforced. The cause of action disclosed by the plaintiff’s petition was a transaction in futures, which was nothing more or less than a gambling adventure; and such an one as that it would be against the policy and spirit of the law to recognize as the legitimate basis of a civil action. It is clear that the contract was simply the sale of one hundred bales of cotton, never intended to be delivered, and in which the seller was simply to pay, at the time of the specified delivery, the difference in the pi-ice of the cotton as it then stood and the price it was bearing at the time of sale, in case of a decline in price; or, on. the other hand, to receive any advance in price, in case the price had advanced, which advance was to be divided between appellants and appellee. In the absence of any statutory enactment with reference to such speculations, the law is well settled that such adventures are but gambling schemes, most pernicious in their tendency and effect, not only upon legitimate trade and commerce, but also upon the morals of the people, and should not be tolerated in law. In some of the states an attempt has- been made to suppress the mischief by legislative enactment. In New York it has been held that “ a contract for the delivery and acceptance of stock at a future day at a price named, where neither party intends to deliver or accept the shares, but merely to pay the difference according to the rise and fall of the market, is void under the statute against betting and gaming.” [Yerkes v. Salomon, 18 N. Y. Sup. Ct. 471; Bigelow v. Benedict, 16 N. Y. Sup. Ct. 429.] Again, “contracts for sale, that ■do not contemplate the actual bona fide delivery of the property by the seller, nor the payment by the buyer, but are intended to be settled by paying the difference in price
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.