G. H. & S. A. R'y Co. v. Schrader
G. H. & S. A. R'y Co. v. Schrader
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
§ 1147. Damages in suit against railroad for killing stock; market value; proof of. Appellee sued the railroad company for the value of six calves killed by its engine and cars. The only proof of value was the testimony of' the plaintiff Schrader, as follows: “My calves were in fine condition; took nearly all the milk from the cows;, were half-breed, the produce of a Durham bull, and showed the Durham stock, and were worth to me $25 per head. I had not sold any calves. The calves were' worth as much in October or September as they would be worth in the following spring. I had paid $25 for a half-breed yearling.” Held, this testimony is not sufficient to sustain the verdict. (The verdict was for plaintiff for $125.) Article 4245 of the Revised Statutes declares that the railroad company shall be liable to the-owner for the value of all stock killed or injured by the locomotives and cars of the company. The value is-the fixed measure of damages, and this value, as a general rule, is to be ascertained by testimony of the price at which such things are bought and sold. If there is a.
§ 1148. Charge of the court; damages; when incorrect, is asked. Where a question of damages is involved, the court should instruct the jury as to the proper measure or rule by which to estimate such damages, and it is error to merely direct the jury to find such amount of damages as they may think the party entitled to under the proof. When an incorrect charge is asked, the court is not bound to correct or modify it, but may properly refuse it, although portions of it may be correct.
Reversed and remanded.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.