G., C. & S. F. R'y Co. v. Key
G., C. & S. F. R'y Co. v. Key
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
§ 257. Common carrier; negligently hilling stock while being transported under contract; measure of damages. Key sued the railroad company for $900 damages for negligently causing a jack to be fatally injured and killed while being transported by said railroad from Navasota to Coleman, Texas. The market value of the animal at Coleman, the destination, was alleged to be $900, and the contract of shipment stipulated that, in case of total loss, the market value at the point of destination should be taken and deemed as liquidated damages for such loss. The jack had been sold by plaintiff to a party at Coleman, the point of destination, before he was shipped from Navasota, for the sum of $535. Defendant’s fourth special requested charge to the jury, which was refused by the court, was as follows: “If you further believe from the evidence that the plaintiff, Key, filed a claim for $600 with the station-master at Navasota for the loss of the jack, then plaintiff cannot recover above said sum; but
Reversed and remanded.
070rehearing
ON REHEARING-.
§ 258. Excessive damages; remitter; practice on appeal. At a former day of this term the judgment in this case was reversed and the cause remanded. But for this excess in the judgment we would have affirmed it. Since our reversal of the case, the appellee, A. Key, has entered in the court below a remitter of all the judgment rendered in that court except the sum of $535, the price for which he had sold the jack at Coleman, and has filed in this court his motion for a rehearing to set aside pur former judgment reversing the judgment of the lower court, together with a certified copy of his remitter as filed in the county court, and he asks us upon the rehearing to affirm the judgment of the lower couú for the sum of $535. His motion for a rehearing has been duly served upon counsel for the appellant, and no answer or objection thereto has been filed for the appellant.
Reformed and rendered.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.