First Nat. Bank of Eagle Lake v. Robinson
First Nat. Bank of Eagle Lake v. Robinson
Opinion of the Court
This cause was decided by this court on November 24, 1909, and appellant’s motion, for rehearing was overruled on January 12,1910. On March 17,1910, appellant filed this motion, asking this court to certify to the Supreme Court substantially all points involved in the decision of the case, claiming for the first time a conflict with decisions of other Courts of Civil Appeals, as to some of the questions.
We recognize a conflict 'between the opinion filed in this cause and the cases of Elmore v. Rugely, 48 Tex. Civ. App. 456, 107 S. W. 151, Young v. Bank, 117 S. W. 476, by the Sixth Court of Civil Appeals, and also the cases of First Nat. Bank v. Campbell, 114 S. W. 887, and Dunovant’s Estate v. Stafford, 36 Tex. Civ. App. 33, 81 S. W. 101, by the First Court of Civil Appeals. The conflict existed at the time of -our decision of this cause; and tve recognize also that we should have certified the question to the Supreme Court before we overruled the motion for rehearing, and we shall state that we would have unhesitatingly done so, had we known of or had counsel called our attention to the conflict. The motion for rehearing is mislaid, but we are quite sure that it made no reference to the cases now cited as conflicting, and no certification of questions was asked upon that or any other ground. We know that we were not advised of the conflict.
The conflict above referred to consists in this:
This court has the power during the term to grant a rehearing for any purpose, but, entertaining no doubt that the decision of the question has been correct in the case, we would not grant a rehearing of our own motion.
We are unwilling to be the first to introduce such a rule into our procedure. We think that, in order to entitle a party to insist upon the certification of a question as a matter of right, he should lay a basis for it and bring the fact of conflict to the attention of the court in his motion for rehearing, or before his motion is finally .acted upon.
The motion is dismissed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- First Nat. Bank of Eagle Lake v. Robinson.
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published