Steger v. Kelley
Steger v. Kelley
Opinion of the Court
This suit was brought by appellee, R. L. Kelley, against the appellants Ed. D. Steger, trustee, and Laura Krause and husband, beneficiaries, to enjoin the sale of land under a trust deed executed by said Kelley to secure certain promissory notes purporting to have been given for the purchase price of land. The allegations, in effect, were that the land was part of appel-lee’s homestead; that 10 years, had elapsed *825 after the maturity of the notes before any attempt to execute the trust deed; and that the notes had been paid in full.
Appellants answered by general demurrer, general denial; that the notes were executed for loaned money to pay off the purchase money notes; that Kelley had executed for the purchase price of the land mentioned in said deed of trust; and that appellant was subrogated to the vendor’s lien, etc.; and that the said notes had never been paid and discharged, but that the same were still due and unpaid.
A -trial resulted in a verdict and judgment for Kelley, and appellants appeal.
The controlling issue in this case is, Were the notes executed by Kelley paid off and discharged, as claimed by him? The notes were executed on March 18, 1890, and made payable to Eli Dubois, or order. The transaction was had through Ed. D. Steger, the representative of Dubois. In 1901 Kelley claims he had a final settlement with Ed. D. Steger, who still represented the heirs of said Eli Dubois, in which settlement said notes were fully paid off and discharged. That he paid to said Steger $350 in cash, and delivered to him an insurance policy, paid up, and valued at $750. That said cash and said policy were received by Steger in full settlement of said notes. Steger claims that said policy was taken only as collateral security and so held by him, and was not taken as a payment on the notes.
The holding that the notes had been paid off and discharged settles this case against the appellants, and therefore we think it unnecessary to discuss the other assignments of error, as they do not affect the case.
The judgment is affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Steger v. Kelley. [Fn&8224]
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published