Herrington v. Gulf, C. & S. F. Ry. Co.
Herrington v. Gulf, C. & S. F. Ry. Co.
Opinion of the Court
On the 22d day of April, 1909, plaintiff, Herrington, instituted this suit in the county court of Tom Green county against the Gulf,' Colorado & Santa Fé Railway Company, the Ft. Worth & Rio Grande Railway Company, and the Ft. Worth & Denver City Railway Company for the recovery of damages, as hereinafter stated, to a shipment of horses from San Angelo to Childress over said respective lines of railway, alleging that said horses were delivered by him to the first-mentioned defendant at San Angelo, Tex., on November 30, 1907, and asserting an additional liability to plaintiff, as against the last-named defendant, for a penalty of $350, under article 326 of the Revised Civil Statutes. Defendants excepted to the plaintiff’s petition, on the ground, that it showed that the amount involved Was in excess of the jurisdiction of said court. This exception was sustained, and the ease dismissed, which ruling furnishes the basis for the first assignment of error.
The petition is not set out in the transcript, but from an agreed statement of the pleadings and proof, made in accordance with article 1414 of the Revised Statutes, and incorporated in the transcript,' we take the following excerpt from .the original petition, which is sufficient to illustrate the point in question. After alleging negligence on the part of defendants in the transportation of said horses, plaintiff, for cause of action and prayer for relief, says: That, by reason of the aforesaid negligence and breach of contract by said defendants, one of plaintiff’s said live stock, to wit, a mare, of the value of $85, was killed, and was a total loss to plaintiff, to his damage in the sum of $85; two other mares, of the value of $100 each, were seriously injured, to plaintiff’s damage in the sum of $90 on one and $95 on .the other; and that the remaining 35 head were damaged in the suin of $350, to his total damage in the sum of $620, which sum plaintiff sues for, together with interest and costs of suit. Plaintiff further sues defendant Ft. Worth & Denver City Railway Company for the penal sum of $350 for the failure of said defendant to sufficiently feed and water said stock. Plaintiff prays that defendants may be cited in terms of the law to answer this complaint, and that upon final hearing hereof he may be awarded judgment against defendants in the total sum of $970, his interest, and costs of suit. It further appears from said agreed statement that said suit was filed on the 22d of April, 1909, and that the horses were delivered to the initial carrier, the Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fé Railway Company, on November 30, 1907.
While there are other questions presented by the brief of counsel for appellant, still, since they have agreed that the judgment as rendered shall be affirmed, unless the Court of Civil Appeals shall hold that the plaintiff’s demand against the defendants as pleaded in his original petition did not, in the aggregate, exceed the sum of $1,000,. it will be unnecessary to consider such assignments.
No error appearing in the judgment of the trial court, we conclude that the same should, in all things, be affirmed, and it is so ordered.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- HERRINGTON v. GULF, C. & S. F. RY. CO. Et Al.
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published