National Ben Franklin Fire Ins. Co. v. Scott
National Ben Franklin Fire Ins. Co. v. Scott
Opinion of the Court
Defendant in error, Scott, sued plaintiff in error, fire insurance1 company, upon a policy of fire insurance covering a. certain automobile; the petition being filed August 9, 1918. Citation was issued August 9, 1918, commanding the sheriff or any constable of Childress county to summon the National Ben Franklin Fire Insurance Company, by service of citation on Crawford & Crawford, a copartnership composed of II. S. Crawford and J. M. Crawford, upon either of whom citation may be had, to appear before the county court of Childress county at the next regular term, to be held at the courthouse in Childress on the first Monday in October, 1918, same being October 7, 1918, then and there to answer plaintiff’s petition filed in suit in that court-on August 8, 1918, wherein Reid B. Scott is plaintiff ahd the National Ben Franklin Fire Insurance Company is defendant, the file number of said suit being 538. The citation then states the nature of plaintiff’s demand, etc. The sheriff’s return recites:
“The citation came to hand on the 10th day of August, 1918, at 10 o’clock a. m., and was executed in Childress county, Tex., by delivering to each of the within named defendants in person a true copy of this citation (together with the accompanying certified copy of plaintiff’s petition) at the following times and places, to wit: [Showing that service was made on August 10, 1918, on H. S. Crawford, at 11:30 a. m.].”
Based upon this service judgment was rendered against appellant by default October 14, 1918, for the sum of $545.90, with interest and costs.
“The statute is plain and easily complied with. To authorize a judgment by default the service should be in conformity with its terms, and on appeal the record, outside of the recitals of the judgment, should disclose it. No one can say from this record whether Banks was a local agent or not. It does not appear affirmatively that he was such. Eor this reason, We believe the judgment by default should not have been granted,” etc.
Eor the errors indicated, the judgment is reversed and the cause remanded.
(fe^For other cases see same topic and KEY-NUMBER in all Key-Numbered Digests and Indexes
Reference
- Full Case Name
- National Ben Franklin Fire Ins. Co. v. Scott.
- Cited By
- 14 cases
- Status
- Published