McGill v. Reed
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Marilyn MacLeod Reed v. John William Reed (Tenn. Ct. App. 2004)
- O'Brien v. Smith (Tex. App. 1938)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Appellee, J. B. Reed, sued appellants, Ellie McGill and Jim McGill, to recover upon and
The land was the separate property of Alford Hudson, and constituted the homestead of himself and family at the time of his death. He was survived by his widow, Ada Hudson, and three children, Ehgene Hudson, Magnolia Hudson, and Bernice Hudson, his sole heirs. Ada Hudson married Oaliph Rose-borough. She was appointed by the probate court of Titus county and qualified as guardian of the estate of said minors, Eugene, Magnolia, and Bernice Hudson. A few months before becoming 21 years of age, and while the guardianship proceedings were still pending on his estate, Eugene Hudson conveyed his ⅛ undivided interest in the land to I. N. Williams. Eugene Hudson was joined in this deed by Ada Roseborough and Oaliph Roseborough. The deed recites that Eugene Hudson is over 21 years of age, and expressly conveys and quitclaims any and all homestead rights of Ada Roseborough, agreeing that partition may be had by the grantee or his assigns at any time. No attempt was ever made by any one to set this deed aside. Eugene Hudson arrived at the age of twenty-one years and later died without having disaffirm-ed the conveyance. Appellants recognize the general rule that a deed of a minor is not void, and only voidable at the instance of the minor within a reasonable time after he reached his majority. But, appellants contend, the deed of the minor, Eugene Hudson, was void by reason of the pendency of the guardianship on his estate at the time he executed the conveyance. We are of the opinion that appellants’ contention is not well taken. The deed of a minor operates to convey title as does that of an adult, but is subject to being defeated within the proper time and manner by reason of his minority, which is a protection afforded the minor and not the purchaser, and, if not so defeated, the conveyance remains valid. The jurisdiction of the probate court would not of itself destroy the power of the minor to convey, but only subject the deed' to being defeated by subsequent exercise of such jurisdiction to that effect' during the pendency of the guardianship proceedings. Nothing having been done to defeat the deed of Eugene Hudson, it remains valid,
The minor Bernice Hudson still resides on the old home place, the land in controversy, and owns a ⅛ undivided interest in it. Appellants testify these facts were known to them at the time they purchased, hence they took subject to whatever homestead rights, if any, she has in the land. At the time of the death of his father, Ehgene Hudson became vested with title to a ⅛ undivided interest in the land, and should appellants be correct in their contention that
We have considered all of appellants’ assignments, and find no error presented.
The judgment of the'trial court is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.