Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2006

Henry F. Fields and Koma Beryl Mahler Fields, Trustees of the Fields Mineral Trust v. Brighton Energy, L.L.C.

Henry F. Fields and Koma Beryl Mahler Fields, Trustees of the Fields Mineral Trust v. Brighton Energy, L.L.C.
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided April 3, 2006

Henry F. Fields and Koma Beryl Mahler Fields, Trustees of the Fields Mineral Trust v. Brighton Energy, L.L.C.

Opinion

NO. 07-04-0118-CV


IN THE COURT OF APPEALS


FOR THE SEVENTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS


AT AMARILLO


PANEL E


APRIL 3, 2006

______________________________


HENRY F. FIELDS, et al.,


Appellants



v.


RICHARD A. WATERFIELD, et al.,


Appellees

_________________________________


FROM THE 31ST DISTRICT COURT OF ROBERTS COUNTY;


NO. 1841; HON. STEVEN R. EMMERT, PRESIDING

_______________________________


On Motion for Rehearing

_______________________________



Before QUINN, C.J., REAVIS, J. and BOYD, S.J. (1)

Pending before us are the motions for rehearing of the litigants asking that we resolve other additional issues and that we affirm those portions of the trial court judgment which no one disputes. We grant and deny the motions in part as described below.

To the extent that the litigants ask the court to address other issues raised in their briefs, we conclude that the disposition of same was and is premature since each will be affected by the validity of the pooling agreement. In other words, if the pooling agreement is ultimately found invalid, they become moot.

As to modifying our judgment to affirm those portions of the trial court judgment to which no one has dispute, we do so. Accordingly, we withdraw our prior judgment, affirm those paragraphs of the trial court's judgment numbered "1," "3," "4," "10," "15," "17," and "18," reverse the remainder of the trial court's judgment, and remand the cause for further proceedings. Finally, except to the extent expressly granted by this order, the motions for rehearing are denied.



Brian Quinn

Chief Justice



1. John T. Boyd, Chief Justice (Ret.), Seventh Court of Appeals, sitting by assignment. Tex. Gov't Code Ann. §75.002(a)(1) (Vernon 2005).

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.