Lee Miller v. R. Henderson
Opinion
In The Court of Appeals
Sixth Appellate District of Texas at Texarkana
No. 06-12-00093-CV LEE MILLER, Appellant
V. R. HENDERSON, ET AL., Appellees On Appeal from the County Court at Law
Bowie County, Texas Trial Court No. 10C0951-CCL
Before Morriss, C.J., Carter and Moseley, JJ.
Memorandum Opinion by Justice Carter
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Lee Miller appeals the dismissal of his Chapter 14 lawsuit by the County Court at Law. We affirm the judgment of the trial court.
I. Background
Lee Miller is an inmate of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice Correctional Institutions Division (TDCJ-CID), currently housed at the Telford Unit in New Boston. Miller filed a pro se and in forma pauperis lawsuit against defendants Rosalind Henderson, David Hudson, Nita Burgess, Casterderia Peters, and Susan Bauer, 1 all employees of the TDCJ-CID, alleging numerous violations of his civil rights after defendants allegedly lost certain items of Miller’s personal property. 2 The lawsuit was filed in January 2010 in the Justice Court of Bowie County, Precinct 2, Place 1. 3
Miller’s Chapter 14 claims were dismissed by the Justice Court on April 6, 2010, for “failure to comply with Chapter Fourteen of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code.” On May 7, 2010, Miller filed his notice of appeal of the Justice Court’s dismissal order to the County Court at Law of Bowie County. 4 On June 28, 2010, Miller filed an affidavit of inability to pay costs in the County Court at Law.
Thereafter, in August 2012, Henderson filed a motion in the County Court at Law to dismiss Miller’s appeal, alleging that Miller did not timely file his notice of appeal. 5 Henderson claimed that because Miller’s notice of appeal was untimely, the County Court at Law had no jurisdiction over the appeal. Henderson further moved for dismissal for want of prosecution, contending that Miller took no action to prosecute his appeal since the filing of the June 2010 affidavit. On August 29, 2012, the County Court at Law entered an order dismissing Miller’s appeal. 6 In September 2012, Miller filed a document in the County Court at Law requesting that his lawsuit be reinstated. 7 In the present appeal, Miller complains of the dismissal of his lawsuit by the County Court at Law. 8 Henderson claims Miller failed to perfect his appeal in the County Court at Law.
II. Standard of Review
The requirements for perfecting an appeal from a justice court to a county court are jurisdictional. Almahrabi v. Booe, 868 S.W.2d 8, 10 (Tex. App.—El Paso 1993, no writ). We, therefore, review de novo the trial court’s dismissal of Miller’s lawsuit. See TRST Corpus, Inc. v. Fin. Ctr, Inc., 9 S.W.3d 316, 320 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 1999, pet. denied) (because question of subject-matter jurisdiction is legal question, ruling on plea to jurisdiction is reviewed de novo). 9 III. Jurisdiction
Henderson contends that because Miller failed to timely perfect his appeal from the Justice Court to the County Court at Law, the County Court at Law did not have jurisdiction over Miller’s appeal. 10 From this premise, Henderson claims this Court, therefore, lacks jurisdiction over the appeal from the County Court at Law. 11 We agree.
To perfect an appeal from a justice court to a county court, the appealing party must file either an appeal bond or an affidavit of inability to pay. TEX. R. CIV. P. 571–73; 12 Rowe v. § 22.220(a) (West Supp. 2012) (“each court of appeals has appellate jurisdiction of all civil cases within its district of which the district or county courts have jurisdiction when the amount in controversy or the judgment rendered exceeds $250, exclusive of interest and costs”).
Watkins, 340 S.W.3d 860, 862–63 (Tex. App.—El Paso 2011, no pet.) (compliance with appellate requirements of Rule 571 is jurisdictional). Rule 572 requires an appellant who is unable to pay the costs of an appeal or to provide security for those costs to file an affidavit of such inability “within five days after the judgment or order overruling motion for new trial is signed . . . .” TEX. R. CIV. P. 572. According to Rule 573, the appeal is perfected “[w]hen the bond, or the affidavit in lieu thereof, provided for in the rules applicable to justice courts, has been filed and the previous requirements have been complied with . . . .” TEX. R. CIV. P. 573. Whenever an appeal has been perfected from the justice court, the cause shall be tried de novo in the county court and judgment shall be rendered. See TEX. R. CIV. P. 574b.
The aforementioned requirements have been interpreted as jurisdictional. In Almahrabi, the court stated:
In order to perfect an appeal to the county or district court from a justice court, an appellant must:
(1) file an appeal bond as required by Rule 571 or file an affidavit of inability to pay under Rule 572; and
(2) pay to the county clerk, within 20 days after being notified to do so by the county clerk, the costs on appeal as required by Rule 143a.
Compliance with each of the above requirements is jurisdictional, and as the language in Rule 573 indicates, only compliance therewith will act to perfect the appeal.
Almahrabi, 868 S.W.2d at 10; see also Litoff v. Meadows Serv. Corp., 352 S.W.3d 894, 896 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2011, no pet.) (compliance with Rules 571 and 573 is jurisdictional); Ashley Furniture Indus., Inc. v. The Law Office of David Pierce, 311 S.W.3d 595, 598 (Tex. App.—El Paso 2010, no pet.).
In lieu of posting a bond, Miller filed an affidavit of indigence in the County Court at Law. Rule 572 requires that affidavits of indigence be filed within five days of the date the judgment of the justice court is signed. TEX. R. CIV. P. 572. Here, the Justice Court’s dismissal order was entered on April 6, 2010. Miller’s affidavit was filed on June 28, 2010. 13 Because the affidavit of indigence was not filed within five days of the date of judgment, it does not meet the requirements of Rule 572. Miller’s appeal in the County Court at Law was, therefore, never perfected. Accordingly, we hold that the County Court at Law was without jurisdiction to entertain Miller’s appeal. 14
Insofar as the County Court at Law was without jurisdiction to entertain Miller’s appeal, this Court is likewise without jurisdiction.
IV. Conclusion
We affirm the judgment of the trial court.
Jack Carter Justice
Date Submitted: February 13, 2013 Date Decided: February 21, 2013
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.