Steffany Jackson v. American Home Mortgage Servicing, Inc.
Opinion
AFFIRM; and Opinion Filed August 4, 2014.
S In The Court of Appeals Fifth District of Texas at Dallas No. 05-12-01596-CV
STEFFANY JACKSON, Appellant
V. AMERICAN HOME MORTGAGE SERVICING, INC., Appellee
On Appeal from the 417th Judicial District Court Collin County, Texas Trial Court Cause No. 417-02539-2011
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Before Justices Moseley, O’Neill, and FitzGerald Opinion by Justice FitzGerald
Appellant Steffany Jackson sued appellee American Home Mortgage Servicing, Inc., alleging that appellee was wrongfully attempting to evict her from her home. The trial judge rendered a take-nothing summary judgment against appellant. Appellant timely appealed. We affirm.
Appellant pleaded four claims against appellee: (1) violations of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, (2) fraud by nondisclosure, (3) trespass to try title, and (4) breach of contract. Appellee filed a motion for summary judgment in which it first attacked every claim on traditional grounds and then attacked every claim on no-evidence grounds. After appellant failed to file a response, the trial judge signed a take-nothing summary judgment in which she stated that the summary-judgment motion was granted “on all the grounds stated therein.” This summary-judgment order became final when appellee nonsuited its counterclaims against appellant and the trial judge signed an order granting that nonsuit.
Appellant raises two issues on appeal. In her first issue, she contends that appellee’s traditional summary-judgment grounds were not meritorious because its summary-judgment evidence was incompetent. In her second issue, she contends that appellee’s no-evidence grounds were not meritorious because they lacked the specificity required by Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 166a(i). We need address only appellant’s second issue.
A no-evidence motion for summary judgment must specifically state which elements of the nonmovant’s claims lack supporting evidence. 1 Appellant argues that appellee’s no-evidence motion is insufficient because it “merely recites the elements of each cause of action.” The record refutes appellant’s argument. The no-evidence portion of appellee’s motion contains the following passage:
Plaintiff has had an adequate time to conduct discovery after filing this suit on June 15, 2011, and she has no evidence supporting one or more essential elements of her claims against AHMSI. Specifically:
a. There is no evidence of the following elements of Plaintiff’s DTPA claims: (1) AHMSI committed a wrongful act under the DTPA; (2) AHMSI’s actions were a producing cause of Plaintiff’s damages; and (3) Plaintiff suffered injury as a result.
b. There is no evidence of the following elements of Plaintiff’s fraud claim:
(1) AHMSI intentionally failed to disclose facts; (2) AHMSI had a duty to disclose such facts; (3) Plaintiff did not have an equal opportunity to discover the facts; (4) Plaintiff acted in reliance on AHMSI’s omission; and (5) Plaintiff suffered injury as a result.
c. There is no evidence of the following elements of Plaintiff’s breach of contract claim: (1) that Plaintiff validly exercised the purchase option; and (2) that Plaintiff was current under the Lease when she exercised the purchase option. d. There is no evidence of the following elements of Plaintiff’s trespass to try title claim: (1) that Plaintiff has any claim to title of the Property. Appellee did not make a general no-evidence challenge to appellant’s case, nor was appellee’s motion conclusory. 2 Rather, appellee identified the specific elements of each of appellant’s four claims that appellee claimed lacked evidentiary support. Appellant did not object that it was unclear or ambiguous which elements were being attacked as without evidentiary support. 3 Thus, any complaints about the clarity of appellee’s motion were waived. 4
Appellant’s sole attack on the no-evidence summary judgment is without merit. Because the no-evidence portion of appellee’s summary-judgment motion is sufficient to support the judgment, we need not discuss appellant’s first issue concerning appellee’s traditional grounds for summary judgment.
We affirm the trial court’s judgment
/Kerry P. FitzGerald/ KERRY P. FITZGERALD JUSTICE
121596F.P05
S
Court of Appeals
Fifth District of Texas at Dallas
JUDGMENT
STEFFANY JACKSON, Appellant On Appeal from the 417th Judicial District
Court, Collin County, Texas No. 05-12-01596-CV V. Trial Court Cause No. 417-02539-2011.
Opinion delivered by Justice FitzGerald. AMERICAN HOME MORTGAGE Justices Moseley and O’Neill participating. SERVICING, INC., Appellee
In accordance with this Court’s opinion of this date, the judgment of the trial court is AFFIRMED.
It is ORDERED that appellee American Home Mortgage Servicing, Inc. recover its costs of this appeal from appellant Steffany Jackson.
Judgment entered this 4th day of August, 2014.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.